SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Immigration, jobs, licenses and students

College Students Charged With Retail Fraud in Michigan

Key points

  • HYTA may be used for an offense committed from the 18th birthday to before the 26th (with the prosecutor's consent from age 21); it requires a guilty plea, and the court decides whether to grant it.[1][2][3]
  • A campus conduct case can run alongside the criminal case. At Grand Valley State University, for example, it uses a "more likely than not" standard and continues even if police drop the charges.[4][5]
  • The 2026-27 federal student aid eligibility handbook limits aid after a drug-conviction hold, during incarceration, and after a conviction for fraud in obtaining federal student aid; it does not use the words theft, larceny or shoplifting.[6][7]
  • International students face federal immigration rules under which a theft offense can be a crime involving moral turpitude, a ground of inadmissibility with a limited exception for a single offense.[8][9][10]

A college student stopped for shoplifting can end up with two separate cases: a criminal case in a Michigan court and, if the school's code reaches the conduct, a student conduct case at the school. At Grand Valley State University, for example, the code says students may be accountable to both, the campus process uses a "more likely than not" standard, and charges dropped by police are not dropped by the university.[4][5] This page covers the issues specific to students aged 18 and older. Except as MCL 600.606 provides, a student under 18 who is arrested goes to the family division of circuit court, explained in juvenile retail fraud charges.[11]

The criminal case is the same as for anyone else

The retail fraud penalties are the same for a student as for anyone else: third-degree retail fraud, the lowest level, is a misdemeanor punishable by up to 93 days in jail, a fine of up to $500 or 3 times the value (whichever is greater), or both.[12] The first steps page walks through the early court dates, and the diversion options page compares the ways a case can end without a public conviction.

HYTA and college-age defendants

The Holmes Youthful Trainee Act (HYTA) is the option most closely tied to age. Since 1 October 2021, a court may use it for an offense committed on or after the 18th birthday and before the 26th birthday, and it requires the prosecutor's consent if the offense was committed at age 21 or older.[1][13] Retail fraud, larceny and embezzlement are not on the list of offenses excluded from HYTA.[14]

  • HYTA requires a guilty plea.[2]
  • It is discretionary, and the court should weigh the seriousness of the offense equally with the person's age.[3]
  • For a charge punishable by 1 year or less, such as second- or third-degree retail fraud, the court places the youthful trainee on probation for not more than 2 years.[15][16][12]
  • The court may require the person to attend a college, university or trade school, or to keep a job, as a condition.[17]
  • If the status is not revoked, the court discharges the person and dismisses the case, and the assignment is not a conviction.[18]
  • Unless a conviction is entered, the records are closed to the public but remain open to courts, police, prosecutors and certain state agencies for use in their duties.[19]
  • The court may revoke the status at any time before final release and then "enter an adjudication of guilt and proceed as provided by law."[20]

The HYTA page covers the details. International students have a separate concern about HYTA, discussed below.

The campus conduct case

Campus discipline depends on each school's own student code, and this guide reviewed only one. Grand Valley State University's published code, "The Anchor" (updated 26 August 2024), is used here as one example, not as a statement of what any other school does.[21]

  • Off-campus conduct. The GVSU code applies on university property and at university events, and also to off-campus conduct that adversely affects the university community or an individual, or the pursuit of the university's mission.[21]
  • Listed violations. It lists "Possession of Stolen Property" and "Violations of Local, State or Federal Law," meaning conduct chargeable under any law.[22]
  • Parallel process. It says students "may be accountable to both the legal system and the University's policies," and that its conduct process "will usually go forward notwithstanding any criminal complaint" arising from the same incident.[4]
  • Lower standard of proof. Its standard is preponderance of the evidence, "whether it is more likely than not" that a violation occurred, while a criminal conviction requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt.[4][23]
  • Dropped charges. GVSU's conduct office says that charges dropped by police are not dropped by the university.[5]

The GVSU conduct office's frequently asked questions page explains its process. Other schools have their own codes and processes. A student facing both processes can ask a criminal defense lawyer how statements made in the campus process could relate to the criminal case.

A civil demand letter from the store

Separate from both the court case and the campus case, a store may send a civil demand letter. Michigan law makes a person who commits an act that could be charged as retail fraud civilly liable to the merchant, in addition to any criminal penalty.[24] The text the statute prescribes for that letter states that the civil proceedings "do not prevent criminal prosecution for the alleged act of retail fraud."[25] The civil demand letter page explains how these letters work.

Federal student aid

The U.S. Department of Education's 2026-27 Federal Student Aid Handbook, Volume 1, sets out student eligibility. It says federal and state judges may deny federal benefits, including student aid, to people convicted of drug trafficking or possession, and that the FAFSA Processing System keeps a "hold file" of people who received such a judgment.[6] It also says students who are confined or incarcerated are ineligible for Direct Loans during incarceration.[6] It defines an incarcerated person as one serving a criminal sentence in a prison, jail or similar correctional institution, and does not count a student in a halfway house or home detention or one sentenced to serve only weekends.[26] A student convicted of, or who pled guilty or no contest to, a crime involving fraud in obtaining federal student aid must repay those funds before regaining eligibility.[7] A full-text search of that 101-page volume found no use of the words theft, larceny, shoplifting or felony.[6] Private scholarships, state grants and a school's own aid can have separate rules, which were not reviewed for this guide. The drug guide's page on drug convictions and federal student aid covers the drug-specific rules.

International students

Students on F-1 or other visas face federal immigration rules that do not follow Michigan's labels. A noncitizen convicted of a crime involving moral turpitude, or who admits its essential elements, is inadmissible unless an exception applies, and the Board of Immigration Appeals has held that theft with intent to deprive the owner permanently, or under circumstances that substantially erode the owner's rights, is such a crime.[8][9] One exception covers a person who committed only one such crime if its maximum penalty was 1 year or less and the sentence imposed was not more than 6 months.[10] Federal law also counts a guilty plea followed by any court-ordered punishment as a conviction, even when Michigan withholds a judgment, which is why HYTA needs careful review for a noncitizen.[27][2] See theft charges and immigration status, and get immigration advice before any plea.

Graduate school and licensed careers

For students headed toward licensed careers, Michigan law limits how licensing boards use criminal records. Michigan licensing boards judging good moral character may not use records of an arrest that did not lead to a conviction, and most boards may consider only felony convictions with a specific link to the license.[28][29] The Board of Law Examiners and a few other bodies may consider any conviction.[30] A profession's own licensing law can add its own rules: nurses and pharmacists, for example, are licensed under a law that requires reporting any criminal conviction to the state within 30 days.[31][32] See theft convictions and professional licenses.

One provision of the set-aside law speaks to schools directly: a set-aside conviction cannot be used as evidence in a lawsuit for negligent admission.[33] The set-aside statute does not say how to answer a school, job or licensing application question about past convictions.[34] The set-aside effects page explains what a set-aside does and does not change. Application questions differ from school to school, so each one is worth reading closely.

Common questions

Can a college discipline a student for shoplifting off campus?

It depends on the school's code. Grand Valley State University's code, for example, applies to off-campus conduct that adversely affects the university community or an individual, and lists possession of stolen property and conduct chargeable under local, state or federal law as violations.[21][22] Codes vary from school to school, so the student's own school code is the one to read.

If the criminal charge is dropped, does the campus case end too?

Not necessarily. Grand Valley State University says its student conduct process and the criminal justice system are separate, that a code violation is resolved through its process regardless of the legal outcome, and that charges dropped by police are not dropped by the university.[5] Its code also says its conduct process will usually go forward despite a criminal complaint about the same incident.[4]

Will a retail fraud conviction affect federal financial aid?

The 2026-27 Federal Student Aid Handbook volume on student eligibility describes a drug abuse hold for people a judge has denied federal benefits after a drug conviction, says incarcerated students are ineligible for Direct Loans during incarceration, and requires a student convicted of fraud in obtaining federal student aid to repay those funds before regaining eligibility.[6][7] That volume does not use the words theft, larceny, shoplifting or felony.[6] Scholarships and school aid can have their own rules, which were not reviewed for this guide.

Does HYTA keep a retail fraud case off a student's public record?

If the student completes HYTA without revocation, the court discharges the student and dismisses the case, and the assignment is not a conviction.[18] Unless a conviction is entered, the proceedings are closed to public inspection, though Michigan courts, law enforcement, prosecutors and certain state agencies can still see them.[19] Closed to the public is not the same as erased.

Can a college student get HYTA for retail fraud?

Possibly. HYTA covers an offense committed on or after the 18th birthday and before the 26th, and theft offenses are not on its exclusion list.[1][14] The person must plead guilty, the prosecutor must consent if the offense was committed at 21 or older, and the decision is discretionary.[2][13][3] The court may require the student to keep attending college as a condition.[17]

Sources

  1. MCL 762.11(1), (2) — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCL 762.11(2); People v Dash, 216 Mich App 412 (1996) (as described in benchbook) — Michigan Courts
  3. People v Khanani, 296 Mich App 175 (2012); People v Bobek, 217 Mich App 524 (1996) (as quoted in benchbook) — Michigan Courts
  4. GVSU, The Anchor (updated 8-26-2024), §§ 3.2.7, 6.0, 7.3 — gvsu.edu
  5. GVSU Office of Student Conduct and Conflict Resolution, Frequently Asked Questions — gvsu.edu
  6. 2026-2027 Federal Student Aid Handbook, Volume 1 (Student Eligibility), Chapter 1 ("Drug abuse hold"; "Confined or Incarcerated Individuals and Prison Education Programs") — fsapartners.ed.gov
  7. 2026-2027 Federal Student Aid Handbook, Volume 1 (Student Eligibility), Chapter 3 (PDF pages 78-79) — fsapartners.ed.gov
  8. 8 USC 1182(a)(2)(A)(i)(I) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  9. Matter of Diaz-Lizarraga, 26 I&N Dec 847 (BIA 2016) — justice.gov
  10. 8 USC 1182(a)(2)(A)(ii) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  11. MCL 764.27; MCL 764.27 (History: Am. 2019, Act 103, Eff. Oct. 1, 2021) — Michigan Legislature
  12. MCL 750.356d(4) — Michigan Legislature
  13. MCL 762.11(2) — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCL 762.11(3) — Michigan Legislature
  15. MCL 762.13(3) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 750.356d(1) — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCL 762.11(5)-(6); MCL 762.13(5) — Michigan Legislature
  18. MCL 762.14(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 762.14(4) — Michigan Legislature
  20. MCL 762.12(1)-(3) — Michigan Legislature
  21. Grand Valley State University, Student Code: The Anchor of Student Rights and Responsibilities (updated 8-26-2024), § 3.1 — gvsu.edu
  22. GVSU, The Anchor (updated 8-26-2024), §§ 5.2.18, 5.2.26 — gvsu.edu
  23. M Crim JI 23.13 — Michigan Courts
  24. MCL 600.2953(1) — Michigan Legislature
  25. MCL 600.2953(2) — Michigan Legislature
  26. 2026-2027 Federal Student Aid Handbook, Volume 1 (Student Eligibility), Chapter 1, "Confined or Incarcerated Individuals and Prison Education Programs" (PDF page 38) — fsapartners.ed.gov
  27. 8 USC 1101(a)(48)(A), (B) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  28. MCL 338.43(1) — Michigan Legislature
  29. MCL 338.42(2) — Michigan Legislature
  30. MCL 338.42(3) — Michigan Legislature
  31. MCL 333.17211(1); MCL 333.17711(1) — Michigan Legislature
  32. MCL 333.16222(3) — Michigan Legislature
  33. MCL 780.622(8) — Michigan Legislature
  34. MCL 780.622(1)-(10); MCL 780.623(1)-(7) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.