SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Records and set-aside

What a Theft Set-Aside Does in Michigan, and Who Can Still See the Record

Key points

  • After a set-aside, the person is considered not to have been previously convicted "for purposes of the law," except as MCL 780.622 and 780.623 provide.[1]
  • Apart from the person's own copy, the Michigan State Police nonpublic record is available only to courts, judicial-branch agencies, the Department of Corrections, law enforcement, prosecutors, the Attorney General and the Governor, and only for listed purposes.[2][3][4]
  • A set-aside retail fraud or larceny conviction can still be used as a prior to charge a later offense at a higher level and for habitual-offender sentencing.[5][6][7]
  • A set-aside does not refund fines, cancel restitution or affect a victim's civil lawsuit.[8][9][10]
  • USCIS does not treat an expungement or set-aside under a state rehabilitative statute as removing a conviction for immigration purposes.[11]

When a Michigan retail fraud or theft conviction is set aside, the person is, "for purposes of the law, ... considered not to have been previously convicted," except as the set-aside statute itself provides.[1] The conviction does not disappear: the Michigan State Police keep a nonpublic record that courts, police, prosecutors and a few other officials can still use for listed purposes, and the conviction can still count in some later cases.[2][3][5]

This page explains the effect of a set-aside under MCL 780.622 and 780.623, whether the conviction was set aside on application or automatically.[1] Who qualifies, the waiting periods and how to apply are on the pages about setting aside a retail fraud conviction, automatic set-aside and limits on setting aside more than one conviction.

What changes when a theft conviction is set aside

"Expunge" is the everyday word; Michigan's statute says "set aside." The general rule applies to an order entered on application and to a conviction set aside automatically under MCL 780.621g.[1] After an order on application, the court sends a copy to the arresting agency and the State Police.[12] A person whose conviction is set aside automatically is treated as having consented to the State Police nonpublic record.[13]

Several practical effects follow from the statute:

  • The public-facing record changes. Michigan Legal Help, a legal self-help website, describes the result this way: "A conviction that is set aside cannot be seen by the public."[14]
  • The nonpublic record is exempt from disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act.[15]
  • Apart from the authorized uses, a person who knows or should have known of the set-aside and divulges, uses or publishes information about it commits a misdemeanor punishable by up to 90 days, a $500 fine, or both; the person whose conviction was set aside and a victim are exempt.[16]
  • For that exemption, "victim" means an individual who suffered direct or threatened physical, financial or emotional harm from the offense.[17]
  • A set-aside conviction and its records cannot be used as evidence in a lawsuit for negligent hiring, admission or licensure against anyone.[18]

Who can still see a set-aside conviction

The State Police keep a nonpublic record of the order (or the notice of an automatic set-aside) together with the arrest, fingerprints, conviction and sentence.[2] By statute it is available "only" to a court, an agency of the judicial branch, the Department of Corrections, a law enforcement agency, a prosecuting attorney, the Attorney General or the Governor, on request and only for listed purposes.[2] Private employers, landlords and schools are not on that list.[2]

Some of the listed purposes (MCL 780.623(2))What it means in practice
Licensing by an agency of the judicial branchA judicial-branch licensing body may consider the conviction.[3]
Showing a prior set-asideA court can see that someone applying for another set-aside already had one.[3]
Sentencing for a later serious offenseA court sentencing a later offense punishable as a felony or by more than 1 year may consider it.[3]
PardonsThe Governor may consider it when the person applies for a pardon for another offense.[3]
Police and corrections jobsThe Department of Corrections or a law enforcement agency may consider it when the person applies to work there.[3]
Charging, plea offers and sentencingCourts, police, prosecutors and the Attorney General may use it in making those decisions.[3]

The person can see it too. The State Police must provide a copy of the nonpublic record to the person whose conviction was set aside, for a fee set the same way as Freedom of Information Act fees.[4] A fingerprint-based check of one's own Michigan record ($30) returns all history tied to the fingerprints, public and nonpublic.[19] The page on checking your own record explains how to order one.

When a set-aside conviction still counts

The most important exception for theft cases is the prior-conviction rule. A conviction set aside on application or automatically "may be considered a prior conviction" by a court, police agency, prosecutor or the Attorney General when charging a crime as a second or later offense and for habitual-offender sentencing under MCL 769.10 to 769.12.[5]

Retail fraud is graded partly by prior convictions, so this matters. Third-degree retail fraud committed by someone with a prior conviction for retail fraud, larceny, larceny in a building or false pretenses (or a matching local ordinance) is second-degree retail fraud.[6] Second-degree conduct by someone with a prior conviction for first- or second-degree retail fraud, larceny, larceny in a building or false pretenses becomes first-degree retail fraud, a felony punishable by up to 5 years.[7][20] Two kinds of prior do not count for that step: third-degree retail fraud, which is not on the statute's list, and the under-$200 larceny and false-pretenses tiers, which the statute excludes.[7][21] The page on how a prior conviction raises the degree covers the details.

A set-aside conviction also counts in felony sentencing guidelines: for scoring prior record variables, "conviction" includes a conviction set aside under the set-aside act, and also an assignment to youthful trainee (HYTA) status.[22]

Finally, an automatic set-aside can be undone. The court must reinstate an automatically set-aside conviction if it was not eligible, and must reinstate one when, on a motion by a person owed restitution or on its own motion, it finds the person has not made a good-faith effort to pay ordered restitution.[23] Before reinstating for unpaid restitution, the court must give notice and an opportunity to be heard.[24]

What a set-aside does not undo

  • Money already paid stays paid: the person is not entitled to a refund of any fine, costs or other money paid because of the conviction.[8]
  • Restitution is still owed, and the convicting court keeps its power to enforce a restitution order.[9] The restitution page explains how those orders work.
  • A crime victim's right to bring or defend a civil action for damages is not affected.[10]
  • The set-aside does not create a right to sue for damages for time served under the sentence.[25]
  • The person can still rely on the conviction to bar a new prosecution for the same offense.[26]

Federal law and other places that follow their own rules

Michigan's rule that the person is "considered not to have been previously convicted" governs Michigan law.[1] Other systems decide for themselves what a Michigan set-aside means:

  • Immigration. USCIS says an expunged record of conviction does not remove the underlying conviction for immigration purposes, citing Board of Immigration Appeals decisions on state rehabilitative statutes.[11] See theft charges and immigration status.
  • Firearms. Michigan's felon-in-possession statute does not apply to a set-aside conviction unless the order expressly says the person may not possess a firearm or ammunition.[27] The federal definition of a disqualifying conviction says a conviction that has been expunged or set aside is not counted unless the order expressly provides that the person may not ship, transport, possess or receive firearms.[28] Second- and third-degree retail fraud are state misdemeanors punishable by 1 year or less, which the federal definition excludes in any case.[28][29][30] See theft convictions and gun rights.
  • Federal job applications. The federal Declaration for Federal Employment (OF-306) asks about convictions in the last 7 years but tells applicants to omit "any conviction for which the record was expunged under Federal or state law."[31] Whether a Michigan set-aside fits that wording is the federal government's call.
  • Bank jobs. Without the FDIC's written consent, a person convicted of an offense involving dishonesty or breach of trust may not work for an insured bank.[32] Exceptions added on 23 December 2022 lift that bar where an order of expungement, sealing or dismissal was issued and the order, or the law under which it was issued, intends the conviction to be destroyed or sealed from the person's record; shoplifting is also exempt once 1 year has passed since the conviction or program entry.[33] Whether a particular Michigan set-aside order meets the expungement test depends on the federal regulator's reading.
  • Canada. Canada's immigration department tells people with a record suspension or discharge from another country to ask the visa office for their region whether it is valid in Canada.[34] See traveling to Canada with a theft conviction.

Background-check reports after a set-aside

Commercial background checks can lag behind the court order. Michigan law protects a business that reported a conviction if the record was public on the date of the report.[35] Under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act, a company that reports public criminal records for employment must either notify the person at the time or keep strict procedures so the record is complete and up to date, meaning its "current public record status."[36] If a report still shows the conviction, the person can dispute it, and the company must reinvestigate free of charge and record the current status or delete the item within 30 days of receiving the dispute.[37] That period can be extended by up to 15 days if the person sends relevant information during it, and a company that reasonably finds a dispute frivolous or irrelevant may end the reinvestigation and must say so within 5 business days.[38] Keeping a certified copy of the set-aside order makes that dispute easier to document.

Answering questions on job and other applications

The set-aside statute states the general rule and its exceptions, but neither MCL 780.622 nor MCL 780.623 contains a provision telling a person how to answer a job, school, housing or licensing application that asks about past convictions.[39] Read each question closely: some ask only about convictions, some ask about arrests or charges, some exclude expunged records in their own instructions, and some come from employers listed in the statute (police agencies and the Department of Corrections) that may see the nonpublic record.[3][31] The employment page covers what Michigan employers may ask.

Set-aside is not the same as HYTA or a juvenile record

Records from a HYTA case or a juvenile case follow different rules. An assignment to HYTA status is not a conviction, and unless the court enters a conviction, the HYTA file is closed to the public but open to Michigan courts, corrections, the state social-services agency, police and prosecutors for use in their duties.[40][41] A HYTA case that was deferred and dismissed still counts as a misdemeanor conviction when deciding whether a person is eligible to set aside other convictions.[42][43] See the pages on HYTA and juvenile theft records.

A common misunderstanding is that "expunged" means destroyed. In Michigan the record moves out of public view, but the State Police keep it, the listed officials can use it, and the person's own fingerprint check still shows it.[2][19]

Common questions

Can a private employer see a theft conviction after it is set aside?

Apart from the person's own copy, the State Police nonpublic record is available only to courts, judicial-branch agencies, the Department of Corrections, law enforcement agencies, prosecutors, the Attorney General and the Governor, and private employers are not on that list.[2][4] Under the set-aside statute, a business that reported the conviction while it was still a public record is not liable for damages or subject to criminal penalties for that report, and under federal law a company reporting public criminal records for employment must keep them complete and up to date or notify the person.[35][36]

If I am charged with shoplifting again after a set-aside, is it treated as a first offense?

Not necessarily. The set-aside statute allows courts, police, prosecutors and the Attorney General to treat a set-aside conviction as a prior when charging a second or later offense.[5] A prior conviction for retail fraud, larceny, larceny in a building or false pretenses can turn third-degree conduct into second-degree retail fraud.[6] A prior for first- or second-degree retail fraud, larceny in a building, or larceny or false pretenses of $200 or more can turn second-degree conduct into first-degree retail fraud, a felony.[7][21][20]

Does a set-aside cancel restitution I still owe the store?

No. The statute says a set-aside does not relieve any obligation to pay restitution and does not affect the court's power to enforce a restitution order.[9] For a conviction set aside automatically, the court must reinstate it if it finds the person has not made a good-faith effort to pay ordered restitution, after notice and a chance to be heard.[23][24]

Can I get a copy of my own nonpublic record?

Yes. The State Police must give the person whose conviction was set aside a copy of the nonpublic record for a fee set the same way as Freedom of Information Act fees.[4] A fingerprint-based record check, which costs $30, also shows both public and nonpublic entries tied to the prints, and the defense attorney who reviewed this guide confirmed that it shows set-aside cases.[19][44]

Does a set-aside help with immigration or a trip to Canada?

Not reliably. USCIS treats an expunged conviction as still a conviction for immigration purposes.[11] Canada's immigration department tells people who received a record suspension or discharge in another country to check with the visa office serving their region about whether it is valid in Canada.[34]

Sources

  1. MCL 780.622(1) — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCL 780.623(2) — Michigan Legislature
  3. MCL 780.623(2)(a)–(g) — Michigan Legislature
  4. MCL 780.623(3) — Michigan Legislature
  5. MCL 780.622(9) — Michigan Legislature
  6. MCL 750.356d(2) — Michigan Legislature
  7. MCL 750.356c(2) — Michigan Legislature
  8. MCL 780.622(2) — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCL 780.622(7) — Michigan Legislature
  10. MCL 780.622(5) — Michigan Legislature
  11. USCIS Policy Manual, Vol. 12, Part F, Ch. 2, § 8 ("Expunged Records") — U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
  12. MCL 780.623(1) — Michigan Legislature
  13. MCL 780.621g(9) — Michigan Legislature
  14. Michigan Legal Help, Expunging (Setting Aside) Adult Criminal Convictions — Michigan Legal Help
  15. MCL 780.623(4) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 780.623(5) — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCL 780.623 (second subsection numbered (6); compiler's note: should be (7)) — Michigan Legislature
  18. MCL 780.622(8) — Michigan Legislature
  19. Michigan State Police, "Find out what remains on your record" — Michigan State Police
  20. MCL 750.356c(1) — Michigan Legislature
  21. MCL 750.356(4)(b), (5); MCL 750.218(2), (3)(b); read with MCL 750.356c(2) (E-051) — Michigan Legislature
  22. MCL 777.50(1), (4)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  23. MCL 780.621h(2), (3) — Michigan Legislature
  24. MCR 6.451 — Michigan Courts
  25. MCL 780.622(6) — Michigan Legislature
  26. MCL 780.622(4) — Michigan Legislature
  27. MCL 750.224f(9) — Michigan Legislature
  28. 18 USC 922(g)(1); 18 USC 921(a)(20) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  29. MCL 750.356d(1) — Michigan Legislature
  30. MCL 750.356d(4) — Michigan Legislature
  31. OPM Optional Form 306 (Revised October 2019), questions 9–11 — opm.gov
  32. 12 USC 1829(a)(1) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  33. 12 USC 1829(c)(1), (2), (3)(D); Amendments note (Pub. L. 117–263, § 5705(a)) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  34. IRCC, "Overcome criminal convictions" — Government of Canada
  35. MCL 780.623(6) (first subsection so numbered) — Michigan Legislature
  36. 15 USC 1681k(a) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  37. 15 USC 1681i(a)(1)(A) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  38. 15 USC 1681i(a)(1)(B), (C); 15 USC 1681i(a)(3)(A), (B) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  39. MCL 780.622(1)-(10); MCL 780.623(1)-(7) — Michigan Legislature
  40. MCL 762.14(2) — Michigan Legislature
  41. MCL 762.14(4) — Michigan Legislature
  42. MCL 780.621(2) — Michigan Legislature
  43. MCL 780.621(2)(c); MCL 28.243(11)(c) — Michigan Legislature
  44. Attorney review: Shawn Haff, Michigan criminal defense attorney, written answers to this guide's questions, 18 Nov 2026 — Attorney review

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.