Key points
- Under the Juvenile Diversion Act, before any petition is filed or authorized, police or a court intake worker may release the minor to a parent and end the investigation, or divert the matter by a referral agreement.[1]
- Retail fraud and larceny are not on the list of offenses defined as a "specified juvenile violation," which the Act bars from diversion, unless charged together with one of those offenses.[2][3]
- A diversion agreement must be in writing, may not run more than 3 months except for a documented treatment program, and may not charge for diversion services.[4]
- The consent calendar is a court track that needs the juvenile, a parent and the prosecutor to agree; the plan is capped at 6 months as a rule, and the court destroys its records after successful completion.[5][6][7]
- After the consent calendar is completed, the State Police keep a nonpublic record open to courts, corrections, police and prosecutors.[8]
This page explains the two ways a minor's shoplifting case can be kept off the formal juvenile court docket in Michigan: diversion under the Juvenile Diversion Act, decided by police or a court intake worker, and the family court's consent calendar. It covers who decides, what each requires, what records are kept and who can see them, and how the two differ. The rest of the court process is on the page about juvenile retail fraud charges; adult options are on the adult diversion options page.
Diversion under the Juvenile Diversion Act
In the Act, "diversion" is what happens when police formally record an investigation or apprehension of a minor and, instead of a court petition, either the minor is released to a parent and the investigation is discontinued, or the minor and parent agree to work with a person or agency to resolve the problem behind the investigation.[9]
Before a petition is filed or authorized, a law enforcement official or court intake worker may release the minor to a parent and end the investigation, divert the matter by a referral agreement, or file or authorize a petition.[1] Restitution "must not be considered when deciding if the minor may be diverted" by referral.[1]
"A minor accused or charged with a specified juvenile violation must not be diverted."[2] That list covers serious offenses such as armed robbery and carjacking; retail fraud and larceny charged on their own are not on it.[2][3]
Screening and the factors officials weigh
Since October 1, 2024, a minor may not be diverted by referral unless the official receives and uses the results of a risk screening tool and a mental health screening tool given by a trained person or agency.[10][11] The screening may not be done on a minor who is currently under supervision in the juvenile justice system by the court or the Department of Health and Human Services, so referral diversion is not open to that minor; release to a parent does not depend on screening.[12][10] Before deciding, the official examines these factors:
- The nature of the alleged offense and the minor's age.[13]
- The nature of the problem that led to the alleged offense.[13]
- The minor's character and conduct, and behavior in school, family and group settings.[13]
- Any earlier diversion decisions about the minor and how the minor complied.[13]
The conference and the agreement
A referral diversion involves a conference with the minor and parent, who must be told the following:[14]
- That taking part in the conference or the referral plan is voluntary.[14]
- That an attorney may come with the minor and parent to the conference.[14]
- What referral programs are available and the criteria for filing a petition or using a referral.[14]
- That if the minor complies with the diversion agreement and referral plan, a petition cannot be filed, or, if one has been filed, it cannot be authorized.[14]
Diversion may not be mentioned or promised during any questioning of the minor, and information the minor reveals at the conference or after agreeing to diversion, before a petition, "must not be used against the minor."[15] Screening results and information given to take part in diversion, "including, but not limited to, any admission, confession, or incriminating evidence," are not admissible in any adjudicatory hearing in which the minor is accused.[16]
The agreement's time to complete "must not exceed 3 months" unless a longer period is documented as needed for a specific treatment program, and it "must not include a term requiring the reimbursement of costs related to diversion services."[4] If no agreement is reached and a petition is to be filed, it must be filed within 30 days after the conference; if the minor does not comply, the official may revoke the agreement.[17]
The consent calendar
The consent calendar is a family court track. At the preliminary inquiry on a petition, the court may refer the matter to diversion, proceed on the consent calendar or place it on the formal calendar.[18] The court may also move a case from the formal calendar to the consent calendar at any time before disposition.[19]
The court may use the consent calendar if it determines that formal jurisdiction should not be acquired over the juvenile, and only if the juvenile, the parent and the prosecutor agree, the court has considered the results of risk and mental health screening, and the court determines the case should proceed on the consent calendar.[5] The court "shall not consider restitution" in deciding whether to use the consent calendar, but the plan must require the juvenile to pay restitution, and no fees or costs may be charged for consent calendar services.[20]
The court holds a consent calendar conference with the juvenile, the juvenile's attorney if there is one, and the parent; the prosecutor and victim "may be, but are not required to be, present."[19] If it appears to the court that the juvenile engaged in conduct that would bring the case within its jurisdiction, it issues a written plan.[21] The rules for the plan:
- It may not remove the juvenile from the parent's custody, and its time to complete may not exceed 6 months unless a specific treatment program needs longer.[6]
- It "is not an order of the court," and violating it may lead the court to return the case to the formal calendar.[21]
- If the court authorized the petition, it may move the case back to the formal calendar only after a hearing, and the case picks up where it left off.[21]
- Statements made by the juvenile on the consent calendar "must not be used against the juvenile at a trial on the formal calendar on the same charge."[22]
No order of disposition may be entered while a case is on the consent calendar, and when the juvenile completes the plan, "the court shall close the case and shall destroy all records of the proceeding."[7] Fingerprints are not taken unless the court has authorized the petition, except as otherwise required by law.[23]
What records remain and who can see them
| Record | Who can see it | How long it lasts |
|---|---|---|
| Juvenile Diversion Act record kept by the court | A person with a legitimate interest, by court order; police and court intake workers only to decide whether to divert a minor[24] | Destroyed within 28 days after the minor turns 18[24] |
| Consent calendar case records while the case is open | The juvenile, parents, guardian ad litem, the juvenile's counsel, law enforcement, the prosecutor and other courts, but not federal agencies or military recruiters[25] | Court records destroyed after successful completion[7] |
| State Police record of a completed consent calendar case | Courts, the Department of Corrections, law enforcement and prosecutors, for their duties or to screen their own employees and job applicants[25] | No end date is stated in MCL 712A.2f(14)[25] |
A diversion record "must not be used by any person, including a court official or law enforcement official, for any purpose except to make a decision on whether to divert a minor," apart from approved research requests, and that section was amended again by 2026 PA 71, effective July 24, 2026.[26] Misusing the record is a misdemeanor punishable by up to 180 days, a fine of up to $1,000, or both.[27]
County courts describe the same ideas in their own words. Muskegon County's family court says that when diversion to alternate services is ordered and completed, "the Petition against the youth is not authorized and is not a public record."[28] Court contacts for West Michigan are on the West Michigan courts page. If a case does end in an adjudication, set-aside rules apply instead, and those are on the juvenile theft records page.
How the two differ
The two routes share a goal but work differently:
- Who decides: diversion is decided by a law enforcement official or court intake worker before a petition is filed or authorized; the consent calendar is decided by the court, with the prosecutor's agreement.[1][5]
- Time limit: 3 months for a diversion agreement and 6 months for a consent calendar plan, unless a treatment program needs longer.[4][6]
- Restitution: it may not be considered in deciding on referral diversion; a consent calendar plan must require it.[1][20]
- If it fails: a diversion agreement may be revoked and a petition filed; a consent calendar case may be returned to the formal calendar.[17][21]
- Records: the diversion record is destroyed within 28 days after age 18; after a completed consent calendar, the court destroys its records but the State Police keep a nonpublic record.[24][7][8]
The store's civil-demand claim is separate from both routes: the civil demand statute lets a merchant sue the parents of an unemancipated minor who lives with them, as the page on civil demands sent to parents explains.[29] The parents' guide puts the steps in order, and the restitution page explains how amounts are set.
Common questions
Can a teenager accused of shoplifting in Michigan get diversion?
Retail fraud is eligible in principle. The Juvenile Diversion Act bars diversion for a "specified juvenile violation," and that list does not include retail fraud or larceny charged on their own.[2][3] Whether a particular minor is diverted is up to the police official or court intake worker, who looks at the offense, the minor's age, character, behavior and any earlier diversions, and since October 1, 2024 must use risk and mental health screening results.[13][10] That screening may not be done on a minor already under juvenile court or state supervision.[12]
Is juvenile diversion the same as the consent calendar?
No. Diversion happens before a petition is filed or authorized and is decided by a police official or court intake worker.[1] The consent calendar is an informal track inside the family court, used when the court decides formal jurisdiction should not be acquired, and it needs the juvenile, a parent and the prosecutor to agree.[5] Their time limits differ: 3 months for a diversion agreement and 6 months for a consent calendar plan, as a rule.[4][6]
Does a diverted shoplifting case leave a record?
The court keeps a diversion record that is open only by court order to a person with a legitimate interest, or to police and court intake workers to decide whether to divert a minor.[24] It must be destroyed within 28 days after the minor turns 18.[24] Using it for any other purpose is a misdemeanor.[27]
Can what my child says during diversion be used against them?
The Act says information the minor reveals at the diversion conference or after diversion is agreed to, before a petition, "must not be used against the minor."[15] Screening results and information given to take part in diversion, including any admission, are not admissible in an adjudicatory hearing in which the minor is accused.[16] On the consent calendar, statements may not be used at a trial on the formal calendar on the same charge.[22]
Does the store still get paid if the case is diverted?
On the consent calendar, yes: the plan must include a requirement that the juvenile pay restitution.[20] Restitution must also be ordered when a case is resolved by a consent calendar or another informal method without a dispositional hearing.[30] For police or intake diversion, restitution may not be considered when deciding whether to divert by referral.[1] A store's civil demand is a separate claim.
Sources
- MCL 722.823(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.823(3); MCL 722.822(e); MCL 712A.2(a)(1)(A) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.822(e); MCL 712A.2(a)(1)(A)-(I) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.825(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.2f(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.2f(9)(b)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.2f(10)-(11) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.2f(14) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.822(b), (d) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.823(5)-(6); MCL 722.823 (History: Am. 2023, Act 287, Eff. Oct. 1, 2024) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.823 (History); MCL 722.825 (History) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.823(2), (4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.824 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.825(1)(a)-(d) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.825(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.829(5) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.825(4)-(5) — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 3.932(A) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 712A.2f(5), (8) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.2f(1), (9)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.2f(9)(d)-(e), (12) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.2f(7)(c), (13) — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 3.932(C)(3) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 722.826(1); MCL 722.827; MCL 722.828(1)-(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.2f(7)(a), (14) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.829(1), (5) and History — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.829(1), (4) — Michigan Legislature
- Muskegon County, 14th Circuit Court Family Division — Juvenile Delinquency Process — co.muskegon.mi.us
- MCL 600.2953(7) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.794(2) — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.