SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Diversion, HYTA and delayed sentences

Prosecutor Diversion Programs for Shoplifting and Theft Charges in Michigan

Key points

  • Prosecutor diversion is run by the county prosecuting attorney, whose written authorization a court generally needs before issuing a warrant or summons.[1]
  • Kent County's prosecutor describes a diversion program for people charged with a non-violent offense and no prior record, covering cases like shoplifting, that requires an admission, full restitution and passing a class.[2]
  • Muskegon County's prosecutor describes an adult diversion program for people with a first, non-violent offense that requires restitution, community service and work with a restorative justice center.[3]
  • Published programs elsewhere, such as Eaton and Lenawee counties, list eligibility rules that include theft under $200 (third-degree retail fraud), no prior convictions and no earlier diversion, and their steps include paying the store's civil demand.[4][5]

Some Michigan county prosecutors run diversion programs that let a person accused of a minor theft, such as shoplifting, complete conditions like a class, restitution or community service instead of going through a full prosecution.[2][3] The prosecuting attorney controls that choice, because a court generally may not issue a warrant or summons for a criminal charge without the prosecutor's signed written authorization, or security for costs.[1] Each county sets its own terms, so practice varies by county and prosecutor.

This page describes what official prosecutor and court pages say about these programs, starting with West Michigan. It quotes conditions only as those pages state them. Court-based alternatives such as HYTA and delayed sentences are compared on the diversion options overview.

The legal footing

Charging decisions belong to the prosecutor. The Michigan Supreme Court has described the choice of the statute under which to prosecute as an executive function exercised by the prosecutor, not the court.[6] Michigan's Crime Victim's Rights Act refers to pretrial diversion directly: in a felony case, before finalizing any negotiation that may result in a dismissal, plea or sentence bargain, or pretrial diversion, the prosecuting attorney shall offer the victim the opportunity to consult and give views, including about "pretrial diversion programs."[7] A parallel provision covers serious misdemeanor cases when the defendant has not already pleaded guilty or no contest at arraignment.[8] Second- and third-degree retail fraud are not on the serious misdemeanor list, although a felony charge later reduced to a misdemeanor counts as a serious misdemeanor.[9][10][11]

The programs below are described on the prosecutors' own pages. Their eligibility rules, fees and steps come from those pages and can change.

Kent County

The Kent County Prosecutor's 2024 Annual Report describes the office's diversion program this way: it "is designed to take those who are charged with a non-violent offense and absolutely no prior criminal record, and give them an opportunity to stay out of the court system and keep their record clean."[2] According to the report:

  • Cases "like shoplifting, many larceny offenses, welfare fraud" are included, where "the defendant admits their guilt and agrees to pay full restitution."[2]
  • Those cases are referred to outside providers, where participants "are required to take and pass a class designed to educate them and prevent any future criminal activity."[2]
  • "If they fail to pass the class, or do not pay restitution, they can be charged with a crime and go through the full criminal justice process."[2]
  • The report says the criteria have "remained virtually the same since inception."[2]

Fees and record outcomes are not described in the passage quoted above. The Kent County Prosecutor's Office is at 82 Ionia Avenue NW, Suite 450, Grand Rapids, phone 616-632-6710.[12] Its Victim/Witness Unit serves crime victims under the Crime Victim's Rights Act, at 616-632-5400.[12]

Muskegon County

The Muskegon County Prosecutor's "Social Justice" page describes "our adult diversion program for first-time, non-violent offenders, allowing them to avoid the criminal justice system."[3] It follows a restorative justice model, "requiring participants to pay restitution, perform community service, and engage with the Mediation and Restorative Justice Center."[3] For eligibility and current details, the prosecutor's office is the source.

Separately, Muskegon's 60th District Court probation department lists a "Retail Fraud Panel" among its probation programs.[13] It appears under the heading "Probation Programs," so it is connected to probation rather than described as an alternative to charges.[13] The Muskegon County Prosecutor's Office is at 990 Terrace Street, Muskegon, phone 231-724-6435.[14]

For other West Michigan counties, the courts and prosecutors are listed on the West Michigan courts page.

Published programs elsewhere in Michigan

Several prosecutors outside West Michigan publish diversion rules that cover retail fraud, which show what such programs can involve.[4][5][15] They do not describe any other county's program.

CountyWho may qualify, per the official pageSteps, per the official pageResult if completed
EatonAdults and juveniles; theft under $200 (third-degree retail fraud); no fighting or resisting police or store employees; no prior convictions; no earlier diversion[4]Apology letter for the merchant; diversion fee and the civil demand fee; restitution for items not recovered or damaged; a meeting; an online shoplifting class with its own fee[4]"the Prosecutor’s office will not issue formal charges"[4]
LenaweeSame four eligibility rules, for adults and juveniles[5]Civil demand fee and diversion fee by money order; written statement and diversion agreement; economic counseling class[5]"the complaint will be closed without prosecution"[5]
Wayne"Offenders with no prior record (or minimal contacts)"; theft offenses, including retail fraud, larceny and embezzlement, are considered[15]Not described in the eligibility memo[15]Not described in the eligibility memo[15]

Wayne County's memo adds that crimes involving "complex schemes, large amounts of money, or a long pattern of criminal behavior may not be suitable for Diversion placement."[15] In Eaton and Lenawee, a participant who does not complete all steps "has failed diversion and will be formally prosecuted."[4][5] For a minor diverted under the Juvenile Diversion Act, the statute says the diversion agreement "must not include a term requiring the reimbursement of costs related to diversion services"; the Eaton and Lenawee pages do not say whether or how that rule applies to their fees for juveniles.[16][4][5]

Diversion and the store's civil demand

Two of the published programs make paying the merchant's civil demand one of the steps.[4][5] The civil demand is a separate civil claim under MCL 600.2953, and the statutory demand letter itself says "These civil proceedings do not prevent criminal prosecution for the alleged act of retail fraud."[17] Complying with the demand within 30 days after it is mailed ends further civil liability to the merchant for that act; it does not address criminal liability.[18][17] The civil demand letter page explains that claim.

What happens to the record

Program pages use their own words for the result, such as not issuing formal charges or closing the complaint without prosecution.[4][5] Michigan's fingerprint statute then applies depending on what actually happened:

  • If a person arrested and fingerprinted is released without a charge, the official holding the biometric data and arrest card shall destroy them immediately.[19]
  • If charges are dismissed before trial, the arrest record is removed from ICHAT, the state's internet criminal history access tool, and the arrest record, biometric data and fingerprints are destroyed unless the prosecutor or judge objects within 60 days of the dismissal.[20]

Court-supervised deferrals work differently: a charge deferred and dismissed under HYTA or another listed deferral law is considered a misdemeanor conviction when deciding whether a person is eligible to set aside other convictions.[21] To confirm how a case was closed, see checking a record after a theft charge.

Court-based alternatives

When a prosecutor program is not available or not offered, other routes come from statutes and courts rather than the prosecutor's office:

  • HYTA, which lets a court assign an eligible person who pleads guilty to youthful trainee status without entering a judgment of conviction, with that person's consent.[22] See the HYTA page.
  • A delayed sentence of up to one year under MCL 771.1(2).[23] See the delayed sentence page.
  • Drug treatment court and mental health court, which, with the prosecutor's agreement, may discharge and dismiss proceedings for a first-time participant who completes the program and is not required by law to be sentenced to a correctional facility; drug treatment court adds that the person is not charged with a traffic offense and has not previously had more than one HYTA assignment or listed deferral dismissal.[24][25][26] In Kent County, the 17th Circuit Court's TASC program is a felony mental health court.[27]

Questions about whether a program exists in a particular county, and what it involves, belong with the prosecuting attorney's office or a defense lawyer; a list of questions is on the questions to ask a lawyer page.

Common questions

Does Kent County have a diversion program for shoplifting?

The Kent County Prosecutor's 2024 Annual Report describes a diversion program for people charged with a non-violent offense and no prior criminal record.[2] It says cases like shoplifting and many larceny offenses, where the defendant admits guilt and agrees to pay full restitution, are referred to outside providers for a class the person must pass, and that a person who fails the class or does not pay restitution can be charged.[2]

Is prosecutor diversion the same as HYTA or a delayed sentence?

No. HYTA is a court assignment, after a guilty plea, to youthful trainee status without a judgment of conviction, with the person's consent.[22] A delayed sentence is a court's postponement of sentencing for up to one year.[23] Prosecutor programs are described on each prosecutor's own pages, such as Kent County's diversion program and Muskegon County's adult diversion program.[2][3]

Do retail fraud diversion programs require paying the store's civil demand?

Some published programs do. Eaton County's steps include paying a diversion fee and "the applicable civil demand fee," plus restitution for items not recovered or damaged.[4] Lenawee County's steps include paying the applicable civil demand fee and a diversion fee by money order.[5] Kent County's report mentions full restitution and a class but does not mention the civil demand.[2]

What happens if a person does not finish a diversion program?

The published programs say the case can go forward. Kent County's report says a person who fails the class or does not pay restitution "can be charged with a crime and go through the full criminal justice process."[2] Eaton and Lenawee say a participant who does not complete all steps "has failed diversion and will be formally prosecuted."[4][5]

Does diversion keep a theft arrest off the record?

It depends on how the case ends. If a person is released without a charge, the statute requires the fingerprints and arrest card to be destroyed.[19] If charges are dismissed before trial, the arrest record is removed from ICHAT, the state's internet criminal history access tool, and prints are destroyed unless the prosecutor or judge objects within 60 days.[20] Programs describe their own outcomes, such as not issuing formal charges.[4]

Sources

  1. MCL 764.1(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  2. Kent County Prosecutor's Office, 2024 Annual Report (Prosecutor's message, PDF page 3) — kentcountymi.gov
  3. Muskegon County Prosecutor, "Social Justice" (Step 6) — co.muskegon.mi.us
  4. Eaton County Prosecuting Attorney, Economic Crimes Unit, "Retail Fraud Diversion Program" — eatoncounty.org
  5. Lenawee County Prosecuting Attorney, Economic Recovery Unit, "Retail Fraud" — lenawee.mi.us
  6. MCR 6.301(D); Genesee Prosecutor v Genesee Circuit Judge, 386 Mich 672 (1972) (as described in benchbook) — Michigan Courts
  7. MCL 780.756(3) — Michigan Legislature
  8. MCL 780.816(3) — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCL 780.811(1)(a); MCL 769.5(7) — Michigan Legislature
  10. MCL 780.811(1)(a)(xxiii) — Michigan Legislature
  11. People v Williams, ___ Mich App ___ (2026) (Docket No. 370658, decided April 13, 2026) — michbar.org
  12. Kent County, Prosecutor's Office — kentcountymi.gov
  13. Muskegon County, 60th District Court Probation Department — co.muskegon.mi.us
  14. Muskegon County, Office of the County Prosecutor; Victim Services — co.muskegon.mi.us
  15. Wayne County Prosecutor's Office, "Diversion Eligibility" (August 5, 2024) — waynecountymi.gov
  16. MCL 722.825(3) — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCL 600.2953(2) — Michigan Legislature
  18. MCL 600.2953(3) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 28.243(7), (10), (14)(h) — Michigan Legislature
  20. MCL 28.243(8) — Michigan Legislature
  21. MCL 780.621(2) — Michigan Legislature
  22. MCL 762.11(2); MCL 762.16 — Michigan Legislature
  23. MCL 771.1(2) — Michigan Legislature
  24. MCL 600.1068(1)-(2); MCL 600.1076(4) — Michigan Legislature
  25. MCL 600.1098(3) — Michigan Legislature
  26. MCL 600.1076(4) — Michigan Legislature
  27. Kent County, 17th Circuit Court — Criminal; Juvenile Specialty Courts — kentcountymi.gov

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.