Key points
- Under the felony plea rule, a plea agreement must be stated on the record or put in writing and signed, and it may include an agreed sentence for a specific term or within a specific range.[1]
- Before accepting a felony guilty or no-contest plea, the judge must place the defendant under oath and explain the maximum sentence, any mandatory minimum, and the trial rights being given up.[2][3]
- In a felony case, if the judge will not follow an agreed sentence, the defendant may withdraw the plea, although misconduct between the plea and sentencing can forfeit that right unless the court finds good cause; a judge's decision not to follow a sentence recommendation does not give that right.[4][5]
- Felony firearm carries a fixed 2-year prison term for a first conviction that cannot be suspended and is served before any prison term for the underlying felony.[6][7][8]
- For CPL purposes, 'convicted' includes an accepted guilty or no-contest plea and the payment of a fine.[9]
A plea agreement in a Michigan weapons case is a deal between the prosecutor and the defense that the judge must review on the record. In a felony case, the agreement must be stated on the record or put in writing and signed, and it may include an agreed sentence for a specific term or within a specific range.[1] Before accepting a felony plea, the judge must be convinced it is understanding, voluntary and accurate, and must place the defendant under oath before carrying out the rule's required steps personally.[2] This page explains those rules, the special features of felony firearm, and the effects a plea can have on a concealed pistol license (CPL), on immigration status and on later options. It does not say whether any plea is a good or bad choice; that decision belongs to the defendant with a lawyer's advice.
Where plea discussions happen
In a felony case, the probable cause conference in district court must include discussion of a possible plea agreement and other pretrial matters, and the district judge must be available to take pleas.[10] At the plea hearing, the court must ask the prosecutor and the defense lawyer whether they have made a plea agreement and, if so, confirm its terms with the other lawyer and the defendant.[1]
The rule that governs the plea depends on the court. MCR 6.302 applies to felony cases in circuit court, while a misdemeanor plea in district court is taken under MCR 6.610.[11] The court process page shows where each step falls.
What the judge must cover before accepting a felony plea
| Requirement | Source |
|---|---|
| The plea must be understanding, voluntary and accurate, and the defendant is placed under oath[2] | MCR 6.302(A) |
| The maximum possible prison sentence and any mandatory minimum sentence[3] | MCR 6.302(B)(2) |
| No trial of any kind, and the rights given up: jury, presumption of innocence, proof beyond a reasonable doubt, confronting and questioning witnesses, calling defense witnesses, remaining silent, and testifying[2] | MCR 6.302(B)(3) |
| Some issues that could be appealed after a trial may be given up, and any appeal is by application for leave, not by right[12] | MCR 6.302(B)(5) |
| The plea agreement placed on the record and its terms confirmed[1] | MCR 6.302(C) |
A misdemeanor plea in district court has a parallel list: the court must find the plea understanding, voluntary and accurate, advise of any mandatory minimum jail sentence and the maximum penalty, explain the trial rights given up, and make the plea agreement part of the record.[13] The trial rights may be given on the record or in writing, and in some cases the district-court rule allows a written plea without a personal appearance.[14]
Guilty pleas and no-contest pleas
Under the felony plea rule, for a guilty plea the judge must question the defendant to establish support for a finding of guilt of the offense charged or the offense pleaded to.[15] For a no-contest (nolo contendere) plea, the judge may not question the defendant about participation in the crime, must state why a no-contest plea is appropriate, and must hold a hearing, unless there has been one, that establishes support for a finding of guilt.[15] The district-court rule is similar: questioning for a guilty plea, and for a no-contest plea a decision based on other available information.[16]
For CPL eligibility, both kinds of plea count once the court accepts them. The CPL statute defines "convicted" to include a guilty or no-contest plea accepted by the court and the payment of a fine, as well as a final conviction or a finding of guilt.[9] The domestic violence guide's page on guilty and no-contest pleas explains other differences between the two.
Sentence agreements, recommendations and withdrawal
MCR 6.302(C) separates two kinds of sentencing terms. When an agreement calls for a specific sentence, a range or a prosecutor's recommendation, the court may reject it, accept it after considering the presentence report (and then must impose the agreed sentence), accept it without the report, or take it under advisement.[4] If the court accepts a plea without having considered the presentence report, or takes it under advisement, it must explain that it is not bound to follow either an agreed sentence or a prosecutor's recommendation.[4] If the court chooses not to follow an agreed sentence for a specific term or range, the defendant will be allowed to withdraw from the agreement; a judge's decision not to follow a recommendation does not give that right.[4]
In a felony case, the rules on withdrawing a plea before sentence depend on timing.[17]
- Before acceptance: the defendant has a right to withdraw any plea until the court accepts it on the record.[17]
- After acceptance, before sentence: a plea may be withdrawn only in the interest of justice, and not if withdrawal would substantially prejudice the prosecutor because of reliance on the plea.[17]
- Listed grounds: the defendant is entitled to withdraw if the court says it cannot follow an agreed sentence, if the court says it cannot impose a sentence it had itself said it would impose, or if a consecutive sentence will be imposed and the defendant was not told at the plea that the law permits or requires consecutive sentencing.[17][5]
- Misconduct exception: except as the court allows for good cause, the two sentence-based grounds are lost if the defendant commits misconduct after the plea is accepted and before sentencing, such as failing to appear for sentencing or violating bond conditions or the plea agreement.[5]
Under the felony rules, if a plea is withdrawn or vacated, the case may proceed to trial on any charges that had been brought, or that could have been brought, if the plea had not been entered.[18]
Felony firearm and plea agreements
Felony firearm has its own sentencing rules. A first conviction carries a prison term of 2 years, the term cannot be suspended, and the person is not eligible for parole or probation during it.[6][8] The term is in addition to the sentence for the underlying felony and must be served consecutively with, and before, any prison term for that felony.[7] As summarized in the Criminal Proceedings Benchbook, each felony-firearm sentence runs consecutively only to its own predicate felony, and if the court gives probation for the underlying felony, the 2-year term runs concurrently with the probation.[19][20]
Because of the mandatory term, the advice of rights at the plea matters. In People v Blanton, as summarized in the benchbook, the trial court had not fully advised the defendant of the felony-firearm penalty, and the Court of Appeals held the court did not abuse its discretion in letting him withdraw his guilty pleas to all three charges in the agreement.[21] In People v Pointer-Bey, as the benchbook summarizes it, the Court of Appeals held that whether a defendant is a first-, second- or third-time felony-firearm offender affects only the length of the sentence, not the accuracy of the plea.[22]
The general probation statute does not exclude weapons felonies other than felony firearm: the offenses it excludes are murder, treason, first- or third-degree criminal sexual conduct, armed robbery and major controlled substance offenses, while the felony-firearm statute separately bars probation during its mandatory term.[23][8] Where probation is possible, the court may delay sentencing for up to 1 year so the defendant can show eligibility for probation or other leniency.[24] The felony firearm sentencing page and the probation page cover these rules in full.
What a plea can affect beyond the sentence
Concealed pistol license
A felony conviction bars a Michigan CPL.[25] A conviction for listed weapons and other misdemeanors in the 8 years before an application bars a CPL, and so does a conviction for a second list of misdemeanors in the preceding 3 years.[26][27] Because "convicted" includes a guilty or no-contest plea accepted by the court and the payment of a fine, an accepted plea to a listed offense counts under those look-backs.[9][26][27] See the disqualifying misdemeanors page.
Immigration
A noncitizen who, after admission, is convicted under any law of purchasing, selling, using, owning, possessing or carrying a firearm (as federal law defines it) in violation of any law is deportable.[28] For immigration purposes, a guilty or no-contest plea plus some punishment, penalty or restraint ordered by a judge can be a conviction even where guilt is not formally entered.[29] In Padilla v Kentucky, the U.S. Supreme Court held that defense counsel must tell a client whether a plea carries a risk of deportation.[30] See the immigration page.
HYTA
The Holmes Youthful Trainee Act applies only after a guilty plea to an offense committed on or after the 18th birthday and before the 26th; except for excluded offenses, the court may then, with the individual's consent, assign youthful trainee status without entering a judgment of conviction.[31] The HYTA page explains eligibility and the weapons-specific rules.
Set-aside later
Michigan's set-aside law lets a person with not more than 3 felony convictions apply to set aside all Michigan convictions, but no more than 2 assaultive-crime convictions may be set aside in a lifetime, and no more than 1 felony conviction for the same offense punishable by more than 10 years.[32] See the expungement page.
Questions people raise with their lawyer
- What is the exact offense named in the proposed plea, and what level of offense is it?
- Is the sentencing term an agreement or a recommendation, and what happens if the judge does not follow it?[4]
- How would this plea affect a CPL, a license to purchase, immigration status or a later set-aside?
- Is HYTA or a delayed sentence part of the discussion?
The domestic violence guide's page on plea bargains describes the bargaining process in general, and the defenses page covers the issues that can be raised at trial instead.
Common questions
Can the judge refuse a plea deal in a Michigan gun case?
Yes. Under the felony plea rule, when an agreement calls for a specific sentence, a range or a prosecutor's recommendation, the court may reject it, accept it, or take it under advisement. If the court accepts it without having considered the presentence report, or takes it under advisement, the judge must explain that the court is not bound by an agreed sentence or a prosecutor's recommendation, and that the defendant may withdraw if the court will not follow an agreed sentence.[4]
What is the difference between a sentence agreement and a recommendation?
Under MCR 6.302(C), an agreement for a specific term or range lets the defendant withdraw the plea if the judge chooses not to follow it. A sentence recommendation agreed to by the prosecutor works differently: the judge's decision not to follow the recommendation does not entitle the defendant to withdraw the plea.[4]
Does a no-contest plea count as a conviction for a CPL?
Yes. The CPL statute defines 'convicted' to include a plea of guilty or nolo contendere if the court accepts it, as well as a final conviction, a finding of guilt and the payment of a fine. A no-contest plea therefore counts for the CPL eligibility look-backs.[9][26]
Can a plea be taken back after it is entered?
Under the felony rule, the defendant has a right to withdraw a plea until the court accepts it on the record. After acceptance but before sentencing, withdrawal is allowed only in the interest of justice, unless a listed ground applies, such as the court being unable to follow an agreed sentence or an unadvised consecutive sentence; misconduct after the plea can forfeit the agreed-sentence grounds. If a plea is withdrawn, the case may proceed on any charges that were or could have been brought.[17][5][18]
Does a plea affect immigration status?
It can. For immigration law, a guilty or no-contest plea plus some punishment or restraint ordered by a judge can be a 'conviction' even if guilt is not formally entered, and a firearm conviction under any law can make a noncitizen deportable. Defense counsel must tell a noncitizen client whether a plea carries a risk of deportation.[29][28][30]
Sources
- MCR 6.302(C)(1), (3) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.302(A), (B)(3) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.302(B)(2) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.302(C)(4) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.310(B)(2), (3) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.227b(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.227b(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.227b(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 28.425b(22)(b) — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 6.108(A), (C), (D) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.001(A), (B) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.302(B)(5) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.610(F)(1), (3), (5) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.610(F)(4), (7) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.302(D) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.610(F)(1)(a)-(b) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.310(A), (B)(1), (B)(2)(a), (B)(2)(c) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.312 — Michigan Courts
- People v Clark, 463 Mich 459, 463-464 (2000); People v Coleman, 327 Mich App 430, 441-442 (2019) — Michigan Courts
- People v Brown, 220 Mich App 680, 682-685 (1996) — Michigan Courts
- People v Blanton, 317 Mich App 107, 120-125 (2016) — Michigan Courts
- People v Pointer-Bey, 321 Mich App 609, 618 (2017) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 771.1(1); MCL 750.227b(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 771.1(2), MCL 771.1(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 28.425b(7)(f) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 28.425b(7)(h)(ix), MCL 28.425b(7)(h)(x) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 28.425b(7)(i) — Michigan Legislature
- 8 USC 1227(a)(2)(C) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- 8 USC 1101(a)(48)(A), 8 USC 1101(a)(48)(B) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- Padilla v Kentucky, 559 US 356 (2010) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- MCL 762.11(1), MCL 762.11(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.621(1)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988.