SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Police stops and seized guns

A Gun Found in a Car or Home: How Michigan Law Decides Who Possessed It

Key points

  • For carrying a pistol in a vehicle, the prosecutor must prove the pistol was in a vehicle the defendant was in, that the defendant knew it was there, and that the defendant took part in carrying or keeping it there.[1]
  • If the jury is not convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant knew the weapon was on the person or in the car, the model instruction tells it to acquit of carrying a concealed weapon.[2]
  • For felony firearm, possession does not require ownership: it means actual physical control, or knowing where the gun is and having reasonable access to it, and it can be shared by two or more people.[3]
  • Felon in possession requires knowing possession, and the prohibited-weapon charge under MCL 750.224 (machine guns, silencers and similar items) requires proof that the defendant knew the item was a weapon.[4][5]
  • For carrying a concealed pistol and for felony firearm, the jury instructions say it does not matter whether the gun could fire or was loaded; for felon in possession, the instructions say the prosecutor need not prove the firearm was operable.[6][7][8]

Michigan law does not treat everyone near a gun as its possessor. Whether a driver, a passenger or a person living in a home "possessed" a gun police found depends on the charge, and each charge has its own elements that the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt.[1][2] For carrying a pistol in a vehicle, the model jury instruction asks three questions: was the pistol in a vehicle the defendant was in, did the defendant know it was there, and did the defendant take part in carrying or keeping it there?[1] For felony firearm, possession can be actual physical control or knowing where the gun is with reasonable access to it, and it can be shared by more than one person.[3] This page explains those tests. It does not give advice about searches, questioning or statements to police.

Which charge, which test

The word "possession" works differently across the weapons offenses. The table sets out the elements the model jury instructions list for several charges that can follow when police find a gun.

ChargeWhat the prosecutor must prove about the gun
Carrying a pistol in a vehicle (MCL 750.227(2))A pistol was in a vehicle the defendant was in; the defendant knew it was there; the defendant took part in carrying or keeping it in the vehicle[1]
Carrying a concealed pistol on the person (MCL 750.227(2))The defendant knowingly carried a pistol, and it was concealed on or about the person[9]
Felony firearm (MCL 750.227b)The defendant committed or attempted the named felony and at that time knowingly carried or possessed a firearm[10]
Felon in possession (MCL 750.224f)The defendant knowingly possessed (or used, carried and so on) a firearm or ammunition in Michigan, after the charged prior conviction[4][11]
Prohibited weapons such as silencers or machine guns (MCL 750.224)The defendant knowingly possessed the item and knew at the time that it was a weapon[5]

The pages on carrying a concealed weapon, felony firearm and felon in possession cover each offense in full.

Drivers and passengers: the vehicle charge

MCL 750.227(2) makes it a crime to carry a pistol, "whether concealed or otherwise, in a vehicle operated or occupied by the person," without a license to carry it.[12] The statute reaches occupants as well as drivers. But the model jury instruction breaks the charge into three separate elements, and presence in the car is only the first.[1]

  • Presence: a pistol was in a vehicle that the defendant was in.[1]
  • Knowledge: the defendant knew the pistol was there.[1]
  • Participation: the defendant "took part in carrying or keeping the pistol in the vehicle."[1]

A related instruction says that if the jury is not convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant knew the weapon was in the automobile, it must find the defendant not guilty of carrying a concealed weapon.[2]

The vehicle charge is about carrying without a license. A CPL authorizes the licensee to carry a pistol in a vehicle, concealed or not, anywhere in Michigan, subject to the pistol-free zones, and a resident of another state with a valid license from his or her state of residence is exempt from the pistol part of the statute unless the pistol is carried contrary to a restriction on that license.[13][14] A person without a CPL may transport a pistol for a lawful purpose if it is licensed by the vehicle's owner or occupant under MCL 28.422 and is unloaded in a closed case designed for storing firearms in the trunk.[15] The pistol in a car page and the transport page explain these rules.

Who has to prove a license or exception?

Under MCL 776.20, the defendant bears the burden of establishing an exception such as a license, but "this does not shift the burden of proof for the violation."[16] Once the court finds some evidence of a license was admitted, the jury is told the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant had no license or violated its restrictions.[16][17] When the lawful-purpose transport instruction is given, the jury is told the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant was not carrying the pistol for a lawful purpose.[18]

Possession without holding the gun, and shared possession

For felony firearm, the model instruction defines possession broadly. It begins: "Possession does not necessarily mean ownership."[3] A person possesses a firearm if he or she has actual physical control of it, or "knows the location of the firearm and has reasonable access to it."[3] Under the second form, a person can possess a gun he or she is not holding. The same instruction adds that possession "may be joint where two or more people share possession."[3]

Felony firearm also requires that the person "knowingly carried or possessed" the firearm while committing or attempting a felony, and the instruction states that the defendant need not be convicted of that underlying felony.[10] Under People v Moore (2004), the broader aiding-and-abetting test in MCL 767.39 controls in felony-firearm prosecutions.[19]

For felon in possession, the instruction was amended in September 2019 to say that possession must be "knowing," in line with the felony-firearm instructions.[4] The judge, not the jury, decides whether the prior offense counts as a "felony" or "specified felony," and the jury decides whether the defendant was in fact convicted of it.[11]

A gun found in a home

The pistol part of the carrying-concealed statute does not apply in a person's "dwelling house, place of business, or on other land possessed by the person."[12] When some evidence of that exception is admitted, the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the weapon was carried outside those places.[20]

Other charges are not tied to place in that way. Felon in possession covers knowing possession of a firearm or ammunition "in this state" by a person barred under MCL 750.224f.[4] Felony firearm applies to carrying or possessing a firearm while committing or attempting any felony other than violations of MCL 750.223, 750.227, 750.227a or 750.230, and possession for that charge includes knowing where the firearm is and having reasonable access to it.[21][3]

A separate law governs storage when children may be present. A person who leaves a firearm unattended on premises under his or her control, and knows or reasonably should know a minor is or is likely to be present, must lock it in a box or container or keep it unloaded with a locking device engaged.[22] A violation is a crime only if, as a result, a minor obtains the firearm and either possesses or exhibits it in a public place or carelessly, recklessly or threateningly in front of another person (a misdemeanor), or discharges it and injures or kills the minor or someone else (a felony).[23][24][25][26] The safe storage page covers the tiers.

Loaded or not, working or not

For carrying a concealed pistol, the model instruction says it does not matter whether the pistol was capable of firing or whether it was loaded.[6] The felony-firearm instruction has an optional paragraph saying the same about the firearm, and its footnote states that the prosecutor need not prove the firearm was operable.[7] For felon in possession, the instructions note only that the prosecutor need not prove the firearm was operable.[8] The former defense instruction on an inoperable firearm was stricken as an incorrect statement of the law and deleted in January 2017.[8]

Search warrants and seized evidence

Under MCL 750.238, on a complaint that a pistol or other weapon is unlawfully possessed or carried, a magistrate satisfied that there is reasonable cause to believe the complaint must issue a warrant to search the described person or place and seize the weapon as evidence.[27] An officer who seizes property under a search warrant must make an inventory, give the person a copy of the warrant and the inventory or leave them at the place searched, and keep the property safely for as long as needed as evidence at trial.[28] Whether evidence from a stop or search can be used in court is a separate question this guide does not cover; the drug crimes guide's pages on vehicle searches and motions to suppress discuss those rules.

Common misunderstandings

  • "The car's owner is the one who gets charged." Ownership is not an element of the vehicle charge or of possession for felony firearm; knowledge, and participation or access, are.[1][3]
  • "Only one person can possess a gun." The felony-firearm instruction says possession may be joint.[3]
  • "It was unloaded, so it doesn't count." Under the instructions, whether a gun was loaded does not matter for carrying a concealed pistol or for felony firearm, and operability need not be proved for felony firearm or felon in possession.[6][7][8]
  • "A license is a defense the prosecutor has to disprove from the start." Under MCL 776.20 the burden of establishing a license or other exception is on the defendant; once the court finds some evidence of it was admitted, the jury is told the prosecutor must disprove it beyond a reasonable doubt.[16][17]

The defenses page collects the knowledge and exception defenses, and the seized gun page explains what happens to a gun police take.

Common questions

Can a passenger be charged for a gun that belongs to the driver?

The vehicle charge does not turn on who owns the gun or who is driving. The statute covers a pistol in a vehicle "operated or occupied by the person," and the jury instruction requires proof that the person was in the vehicle, knew the pistol was there, and took part in carrying or keeping it there. Being in the car is only the first of those three elements.[12][1]

Does it matter who owns the gun?

Not as an element. The felony-firearm possession instruction begins "Possession does not necessarily mean ownership," and defines possession as actual physical control or knowing where the firearm is with reasonable access to it. The vehicle-carrying instruction asks about knowledge and taking part in carrying or keeping the pistol, not ownership.[3][1]

Can two people possess the same gun at once?

Yes, under the felony-firearm instruction. It tells jurors that possession may be sole, where one person alone possesses the firearm, or joint, where two or more people share possession. Each person's knowledge and access is still a question for the jury, and the prosecutor must prove the elements beyond a reasonable doubt as to each defendant.[3][10]

Is a gun kept in my own home a carrying-concealed offense?

The pistol part of the carrying-concealed statute excepts a person's dwelling house, place of business and other land the person possesses. Other charges are not limited that way: felon in possession, for example, applies to knowing possession of a firearm anywhere in Michigan by a person barred under MCL 750.224f.[12][20][4]

What if I didn't know the gun was in the car?

Knowledge is an element. The vehicle instruction requires proof that the defendant knew the pistol was there, and a separate instruction tells jurors to find the defendant not guilty of carrying a concealed weapon if they are not convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant knew the weapon was in the automobile.[1][2]

Sources

  1. M Crim JI 11.1a — Michigan Courts
  2. M Crim JI 11.7 — Michigan Courts
  3. M Crim JI 11.34b — Michigan Courts
  4. M Crim JI 11.38, Use Note 1 and History — Michigan Courts
  5. M Crim JI 11.29, 11.30 — Michigan Courts
  6. M Crim JI 11.3(3), 11.34 n 3; People v Peals, 476 Mich 636 (2006) — Michigan Courts
  7. M Crim JI 11.34(6) and n 3 — Michigan Courts
  8. M Crim JI 11.38 n 3; M Crim JI 11.38a n 3; M Crim JI 11.6 [DELETED] — Michigan Courts
  9. M Crim JI 11.1 — Michigan Courts
  10. M Crim JI 11.34 — Michigan Courts
  11. M Crim JI 11.38 and use note 4 — Michigan Courts
  12. MCL 750.227(2) — Michigan Legislature
  13. MCL 28.425c(3) — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCL 750.231a(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  15. MCL 750.231a(1)(d) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 776.20; M Crim JI 11.10, 11.11; People v Henderson, 391 Mich 612 (1974) — Michigan Legislature
  17. M Crim JI 11.10 and Use Note — Michigan Courts
  18. M Crim JI 11.14; MCL 750.231a(1)(d)-(e) — Michigan Courts
  19. People v Moore, 470 Mich 56 (2004); MCL 767.39 — Michigan Courts
  20. M Crim JI 11.11 and Use Note; MCL 750.227(1) — Michigan Courts
  21. MCL 750.227b(1) — Michigan Legislature
  22. MCL 28.429(1); 2023 PA 17 — Michigan Legislature
  23. MCL 28.429(3) — Michigan Legislature
  24. MCL 28.429(4) — Michigan Legislature
  25. MCL 28.429(5) — Michigan Legislature
  26. MCL 28.429(6) — Michigan Legislature
  27. MCL 750.238 — Michigan Legislature
  28. MCL 780.655(1), (2) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.