SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Delivery, manufacture and intent to deliver

Drug conspiracy and attempt charges in Michigan

Key points

  • When the target drug crime is punishable by 1 year or more, a conspiracy to commit it carries a penalty equal to that crime's, and the court may add a $10,000 fine.[1]
  • The MJI benchbook reports that a conspiracy is complete when the agreement is made; no overt act is needed and the plan does not have to succeed.[2]
  • For a conspiracy to deliver, the Michigan Supreme Court held that knowledge of the amount is an element.[3]
  • Attempting, soliciting, inducing or intimidating someone to commit a drug crime carries the penalty for that drug crime.[4]
  • According to the benchbook, a later conspiracy conviction prosecuted under the Penal Code cannot be doubled under the drug repeat-offender rule.[5]

A person does not have to hand over drugs to face a serious drug charge in Michigan. Prosecutors can charge an agreement to commit a drug crime as conspiracy, which, when the drug crime is punishable by 1 year or more, carries “a penalty equal to that which could be imposed” for the drug crime itself.[1] The Public Health Code separately punishes attempting a drug crime, or soliciting, inducing or intimidating someone else to commit one, with the penalty for that crime.[4] And anyone who aids or abets a drug crime may be punished as if he or she committed it directly.[6]

This page explains each route, what must be proved, and the limits courts have recognized. Federal conspiracy law is covered separately in federal drug conspiracy (21 USC 846).

Conspiracy: the elements

Michigan's model jury instruction, M Crim JI 10.1, says the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt:[7]

  1. that the defendant and someone else knowingly agreed to commit the crime;[7]
  2. that the defendant specifically intended to commit or help commit that crime; and[7]
  3. that the agreement took place or continued during the period charged.[7]

The instruction's Use Note says “[a]ny conspiracy to commit an offense is a specific intent crime.”[7] The MJI benchbook describes that intent as two-fold: the defendant must intend to combine with others and must intend to accomplish the illegal objective.[8]

The agreement

The benchbook reports that, under People v Carter, the crime is “complete upon formation of the agreement,” and “it is not necessary to establish any overt act in furtherance of the conspiracy.”[2] The agreement may be proved by circumstantial evidence; a formal agreement is not required, and an agreement in fact “may be proved by circumstances, acts, and conduct of the parties.”[2] Guilt also does not depend on whether the goals of the conspiracy were achieved.[2]

Two people must share the intent

Because a conspiracy needs two or more people, the prosecution must prove that both the defendant and at least one other person had the required specific intent.[8] The benchbook reports that “where only one person can be shown to have had the mens rea to commit an illegal act, no conspiracy exists.”[8] Cases built on undercover officers or informants raise their own issues, discussed in controlled buys and confidential informants.

Joining a conspiracy: knowledge is not enough

A person may join an existing conspiracy by knowingly cooperating to further its object, but the benchbook reports that, under People v Blume, “[m]ere knowledge that someone proposes unlawful action alone is not enough.”[9] The defendant “must know of the conspiracy, must know of the objective of the conspiracy, and must intend to participate cooperatively to further that objective.”[9]

Once a person has joined, the benchbook reports that withdrawal is not a defense under Michigan's conspiracy statute.[10]

Proving the amount in a drug conspiracy

For a delivery charge, the amount is an element but knowledge of the amount is not.[11] Conspiracy is different. In People v Mass, the Michigan Supreme Court held that “knowledge of the amount of a controlled substance is an element of a conspiracy to deliver charge.”[3]

The benchbook states the elements of conspiracy to possess with intent to deliver this way: the defendant and a coconspirator each specifically intended to deliver the statutory minimum charged, and they specifically intended to combine to deliver that amount to a third person.[12] It reports that a jury must be told the defendant conspired to deliver the amount alleged, and that conspiring to deliver “an unspecified amount” is not sufficient.[12]

The benchbook also reports that Wharton's Rule, which bars a conspiracy charge when the target crime itself needs two participants, does not apply to a two-person conspiracy to deliver, because a simple delivery does not necessarily require the cooperative acts of more than one person.[13]

Penalties for conspiracy

Under MCL 750.157a, if the target crime is punishable by 1 year or more, a person convicted of conspiracy “shall be punished by a penalty equal to that which could be imposed if he had been convicted of committing the crime he conspired to commit,” and the court may add a $10,000 fine.[1] Other rules follow from that:

  • Conspiracy and the completed crime are separate offenses, and as a general rule both may be punished.[14]
  • Because a consecutive-sentencing provision is a penalty, consecutive-sentencing rules for the target crime also apply to the conspiracy, according to the benchbook's account of People v Denio.[15]
  • Conspiracy to manufacture, deliver or possess with intent to deliver a narcotic or cocaine, or to possess 25 grams or more of one, is itself a “major controlled substance offense”[16], which the Holmes Youthful Trainee Act excludes.[17]

Attempt, solicitation and intimidation under section 7407a

MCL 333.7407a says “[a] person shall not attempt to violate this part,” and “shall not knowingly or intentionally solicit, induce, or intimidate another person to violate this part.”[4] Except where the minors statute, section 7416, applies, the penalty is “the penalty for the crime he or she attempted to commit, or ... solicited, induced, or intimidated another person to commit.”[4] The benchbook reports that such a defendant is also subject to any mandatory sentence and consecutive-sentencing provisions for the target crime.[18] Recruiting minors is covered in delivering drugs to a minor.

For delivery, an attempt is covered by the delivery offense itself. Michigan's definition of delivery includes an attempted transfer, so the jury-instruction committee notes that attempted delivery is not a lesser included offense.[19] See drug delivery charges.

Aiding and abetting

Under MCL 767.39, “[e]very person concerned in the commission of an offense, whether he directly commits the act constituting the offense or procures, counsels, aids, or abets in its commission” may be tried and punished “as if he had directly committed such offense.”[6] In People v Plunkett, the Michigan Supreme Court held that driving another person to a narcotics purchase, supplying the money and intending it for drugs supported a bindover for aiding and abetting the delivery.[20]

Effect on repeat-offender doubling

Michigan's repeat-offender rule for drug crimes, MCL 333.7413, applies to “a second or subsequent offense under this article,” meaning the controlled substances article.[21] The benchbook reports that, under People v Briseno, conspiracy prosecuted under MCL 750.157a does not qualify, so the doubling provision does not apply to a later conspiracy conviction, while aiding and abetting a drug offense is treated as an offense under the article.[5] It reports that in People v Anderson an attempted-conspiracy conviction also did not count.[22] More is in second drug offense penalties.

Federal drug conspiracy

Federal law, 21 USC 846, makes a person who attempts or conspires to commit a federal drug offense “subject to the same penalties as those prescribed for the offense.”[23] That includes federal mandatory minimums, which are explained in federal drug conspiracy.[23]

Common misunderstandings

  • “No drugs changed hands, so there is no crime.” A conspiracy is complete when the agreement is made, according to the benchbook's account of Carter.[2]
  • “Being around the people involved makes you part of it.” Knowledge alone is not enough; intent to participate must be proved.[9]
  • “A conspiracy charge is a lesser charge.” The penalty equals that of the target crime, with a possible extra $10,000 fine.[1]

Common questions

Can I be convicted of conspiracy if the drug deal never happened?

Yes, it is possible. The MJI benchbook reports that, under People v Carter, conspiracy is “complete upon formation of the agreement,” no overt act has to be proved, and “[t]he guilt or innocence of a conspirator does not depend upon the accomplishment of the goals of the conspiracy.”[2] The prosecutor must still prove a knowing agreement and the specific intent to commit the crime beyond a reasonable doubt.[7]

Is knowing about a friend's drug dealing enough to make me part of a conspiracy?

No. The MJI benchbook reports that, under People v Blume, “[m]ere knowledge that someone proposes unlawful action alone is not enough to find involvement in a conspiracy.”[9] The person must know of the conspiracy and its objective and “must intend to participate cooperatively to further that objective.”[9] Whether the evidence shows that is a question for the jury.

Can someone be convicted of both conspiracy and the drug crime itself?

Generally, yes. The MJI benchbook reports that conspiracy is “a separate and distinct crime from its target offense,” and that as a general rule both may be punished even when they arise from the same transaction.[14] It also reports that a person may be convicted of both conspiracy and aiding and abetting the same completed offense without violating double jeopardy.[14]

Can I withdraw from a drug conspiracy?

The MJI benchbook reports that, under People v Cotton, withdrawal is not a defense to conspiracy under Michigan's conspiracy statute, because “the heart of the offense is the participation in the unlawful agreement.”[10] Whether a knowing agreement and the required specific intent existed in the first place remains part of the prosecutor's burden.[7]

Sources

  1. MCL 750.157a(a) — Michigan Legislature
  2. People v Carter, 415 Mich 558, 568–569 (1982) — Michigan Courts
  3. People v Mass, 464 Mich 615 (2001); People v Justice (After Remand), 454 Mich 334, 349 (1997) — Caselaw Access Project
  4. MCL 333.7407a(1)–(3) — Michigan Legislature
  5. People v Briseno, 211 Mich App 11, 18 (1995); MCL 767.39 — Michigan Courts
  6. MCL 767.39; People v Plunkett, 485 Mich 50 (2010) — Michigan Legislature
  7. M Crim JI 10.1 and Use Note 1 — Michigan Courts
  8. People v Carter, 415 Mich 558, 568 (1982); People v Anderson, 418 Mich 31, 35 (1983); People v Williams, 240 Mich App 316, 325 (2000) — Michigan Courts
  9. People v Blume, 443 Mich 476, 483–485 (1993) — Michigan Courts
  10. People v Cotton, 191 Mich App 377, 393 (1991) — Michigan Courts
  11. People v Mass, 464 Mich 615, 626–627 (2001) — Caselaw Access Project
  12. People v Hunter, 466 Mich 1, 6 (2002); People v Justice (After Remand), 454 Mich 334, 349 (1997); People v Mass, 464 Mich 615, 639 (2001) — Michigan Courts
  13. People v Weathersby, 204 Mich App 98, 107 (1994); People v Betancourt, 120 Mich App 58, 65 (1982) — Michigan Courts
  14. People v Mass, 464 Mich 615, 632 (2001); People v Denio, 454 Mich 691, 695–696 (1997); People v Carter, 415 Mich 558, 579–582 (1982) — Michigan Courts
  15. People v Denio, 454 Mich 691, 703 (1997) — Michigan Courts
  16. MCL 761.2; MCL 333.7401(2)(a)(iv) — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCL 762.11(3)(a)-(d) — Michigan Legislature
  18. People v Gonzalez, 256 Mich App 212, 229–230 (2003) — Michigan Courts
  19. M Crim JI 12.2 and Use Note; MCL 333.7105(1) — Michigan Courts
  20. People v Plunkett, 485 Mich 50 (2010) — Caselaw Access Project
  21. MCL 333.7413(1); History line — Michigan Legislature
  22. People v Anderson, 202 Mich App 732, 735 (1993) — Michigan Courts
  23. 21 USC 846 — govinfo.gov

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.