SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Federal drug law

Federal Drug Conspiracy Under 21 USC 846

Key points

  • Under 21 USC 846, a person who attempts or conspires to commit a federal drug offense faces the same penalties as the offense that was the goal, including mandatory minimums.[1]
  • The government does not have to prove an overt act; the Supreme Court held in United States v Shabani (1994) that no overt act in furtherance of the conspiracy is needed to establish a violation of 846.[2]
  • The Sixth Circuit's model instruction requires an agreement between two or more persons, knowledge of the conspiracy and its goals, and joining it with intent that a conspirator commit the drug crime.[3]
  • A single sale between a buyer and a seller is not enough by itself to prove a conspiracy, and the Sixth Circuit recognizes a buyer-seller exception.[4][5]
  • For a mandatory minimum, the jury must find the drug quantity attributable to the defendant: his or her own conduct plus co-conspirators' conduct that was reasonably foreseeable to him or her.[6][7]

A conspiracy is an agreement between two or more people to commit a crime. The federal drug conspiracy statute, 21 USC 846, is one sentence long: anyone who attempts or conspires to commit a federal drug offense "shall be subject to the same penalties as those prescribed for the offense, the commission of which was the object of the attempt or conspiracy."[1] That means the conspiracy carries the same range, including any mandatory minimum, as the completed drug crime that was its goal.[1]

This page explains what the government has to prove in an 846 case in federal courts in Michigan, the limits on conspiracy that the Sixth Circuit recognizes, how quantity is decided, and how federal conspiracy differs from a Michigan conspiracy charge. The Michigan charge is covered on drug conspiracy and attempt in Michigan.

What the government must prove

Michigan is in the federal Sixth Circuit.[8] The Sixth Circuit's pattern jury instruction for 21 USC 846 lists three elements the government must prove beyond a reasonable doubt.[3]

  1. Two or more persons conspired, or agreed, to commit the drug crime.[3]
  2. The defendant knew of the conspiracy and its objects.[3]
  3. The defendant joined the conspiracy with the intent that at least one of the conspirators engage in conduct that satisfies the elements of the drug crime.[3]

The Supreme Court held in United States v Shabani (1994) that the government need not prove any overt act in furtherance of the conspiracy to establish a violation of 846.[2] The model instruction also tells jurors that the crime exists even if the people involved never actually achieve their goal.[3]

What counts as an agreement, and what does not

The model instruction says no formal agreement, written or spoken, is needed, and the people involved need not have agreed on all the details.[4] What the government must prove is a mutual understanding, spoken or unspoken, to cooperate in the drug crime, and that agreement can be proved indirectly through facts and circumstances.[4]

The same instruction lists things that are not enough without more:

  • people simply meeting from time to time and talking about common interests;[4]
  • people engaging in similar conduct;[4]
  • a single transaction between a buyer and a seller.[4]

Jurors may consider those facts in deciding whether there was an agreement, but the instruction says they are not enough by themselves.[4] The committee commentary also says that an agreement between a defendant and a government agent or informer will not support a conspiracy conviction.[9]

The defendant's connection to the conspiracy

Under the model instruction, the government does not have to prove that a defendant knew everything about the conspiracy or everyone in it, joined at the start, or played a major role; a slight role or connection may be enough.[10] It also need not prove that the defendant knew which controlled substance was involved or how much, as long as he or she knew it was some kind of controlled substance and some quantity was involved.[10]

The instruction then sets limits. Proof that a defendant simply knew about a conspiracy, was present at times, or associated with members of the group is not enough, even if he or she approved of what was happening.[10] Doing something that happened to help a conspiracy does not necessarily make a person a conspirator.[10]

The buyer-seller rule

The committee commentary says the Sixth Circuit recognizes a buyer-seller exception, which "refuses to equate a buyer-seller agreement with a conspiratorial agreement," citing United States v Wheat (6th Cir. 2021).[5] The commentary adds that the exception reaches any distribution, not only sales.[5]

The commentary also says the court has upheld conspiracy convictions where there was more than a mere purchase or sale, and it lists factors that can show a sale was part of a larger conspiracy:[5]

  • advance planning;[5]
  • multiple transactions involving large quantities;[5]
  • repeat purchases or other lasting arrangements, and the length of the relationship;[5]
  • an established method of payment and standardized transactions;[5]
  • the level of mutual trust between buyer and seller.[5]

Drug quantity in a conspiracy case

Quantity matters because it sets the statutory range and can trigger a mandatory minimum.[11][12] Under Alleyne v United States (2013), any fact that increases a mandatory minimum is an element that must be found by the jury beyond a reasonable doubt.[13] The commentary to the Sixth Circuit's instructions says that in 846 cases quantity can raise the maximum or trigger a minimum, so the jury must agree unanimously on a minimum quantity.[7]

The model quantity instruction asks the jury, after a guilty verdict, to find the quantity attributable to the defendant "as the result of his own conduct and the conduct of other co-conspirators that was reasonably foreseeable to him," using a special verdict form.[6] The jury need not find that the defendant knew the offense involved that quantity.[6] The commentary says the Sixth Circuit called this approach "defendant-specific" rather than "conspiracy-wide."[6] The quantity triggers are listed on federal mandatory minimums and the safety valve.

Sentencing in a federal conspiracy case

Because 846 uses the penalties for the target offense, a conspiracy to distribute a 10-year quantity of a drug carries the same 10-years-to-life range as distributing it.[1][11] The drug-trafficking guideline, USSG 2D1.1, expressly covers attempts and conspiracies, and its starting offense level depends on drug type and quantity.[14] The safety valve in 18 USC 3553(f) lists 846 among the offenses it covers.[15] Its leadership condition requires that the defendant was not an organizer, leader, manager or supervisor of others in the offense.[15]

Federal conspiracy compared with Michigan conspiracy

IssueFederal (21 USC 846)Michigan (MCL 750.157a)
PenaltySame penalties as the target offense[1]Same penalty as the target offense when that offense is punishable by 1 year or more, plus a possible $10,000 fine[16]
Overt actNot required (Shabani)[2]Not required; the crime is complete when the agreement is made[17]
Knowledge of amountDefendant need not know how much; knowing some quantity was involved is enough[10]Knowledge of the amount is an element of conspiracy to deliver (People v Mass)[18]
Two-person dealsBuyer-seller exception recognized by the Sixth Circuit[5]Wharton's Rule does not block a two-person conspiracy-to-deliver charge[19]
Shared intentAgreement with only a government agent or informer is not enough[9]Both the defendant and at least one other person must share the intent; no one-person conspiracy[20]
WithdrawalNot covered on this pageNot a defense under MCL 750.157a (People v Cotton, Court of Appeals)[21]

In Michigan, the conspiracy and the completed drug crime can generally both be punished, as explained on Michigan drug conspiracy and attempt.[22]

Attempt under 21 USC 846

The same section covers attempts: a person who attempts a federal drug offense faces the same penalties as the completed offense.[1]

For how a case gets to federal court, see how a drug case becomes federal. For the statutes behind most conspiracy charges, see federal drug charges, and for the steps after a charge, see the federal drug case process and what to expect after a federal drug charge.

Common questions

Can someone be convicted of a federal drug conspiracy if no drugs were ever sold?

Yes. The Sixth Circuit's model instruction says it is a crime for two or more persons to agree to commit a drug crime even if they never achieve their goal.[3] The Supreme Court held in United States v Shabani (1994) that no overt act in furtherance of the conspiracy has to be proved under 21 USC 846.[2] The government must still prove the agreement and each element beyond a reasonable doubt.[3]

Is buying drugs from a dealer a conspiracy with that dealer?

Not by itself. The model instruction says a single transaction between a buyer and a seller is not enough to establish a conspiracy.[4] The committee commentary describes a Sixth Circuit buyer-seller exception, but also lists evidence that can show more than a sale, such as advance planning, repeat purchases, large quantities, standardized deals and mutual trust.[5]

Can a conspiracy be with an undercover officer or informant?

The committee commentary to the Sixth Circuit's instruction says that proof of an agreement between a defendant and a government agent or informer will not support a conspiracy conviction.[9] The "two or more persons" element means there must be an agreement with at least one other person who is not acting for the government.[9][3]

Am I responsible for all the drugs in the whole conspiracy?

For the statutory quantity that sets a mandatory minimum, the Sixth Circuit's model instruction asks the jury to find the quantity attributable to the defendant from his or her own conduct and the reasonably foreseeable conduct of co-conspirators, unanimously and beyond a reasonable doubt.[6] The commentary says the Sixth Circuit called this approach "defendant-specific" rather than "conspiracy-wide."[6]

Does the safety valve apply to a conspiracy charge?

Yes, 21 USC 846 is one of the offenses the safety valve in 18 USC 3553(f) lists.[15] A defendant must still meet all five conditions, including the limit on criminal history and the condition that he or she was not an organizer, leader, manager or supervisor.[23][15] The details are on the federal mandatory minimums page.

Sources

  1. 21 USC 846 — govinfo.gov
  2. United States v Shabani, 513 U.S. 10 (1994), No. 93-981 — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  3. Sixth Circuit Pattern Criminal Jury Instructions, Inst. 14.05(1)–(2) (Conspiracy to Violate the Drug Laws, 21 U.S.C. § 846) — ca6.uscourts.gov
  4. Sixth Circuit Pattern Criminal Jury Instructions, Inst. 14.05(3)(A)(1)–(3) — ca6.uscourts.gov
  5. Sixth Circuit Pattern Criminal Jury Instructions, Committee Commentary 14.05 (current through May 29, 2026), citing United States v Wheat, 988 F.3d 299, 307–308 (6th Cir. 2021), and United States v Hamm, 952 F.3d 728, 736 (6th Cir. 2020) — ca6.uscourts.gov
  6. Sixth Circuit Pattern Criminal Jury Instructions, Inst. 14.07B(1), (2), (4) and Committee Commentary 14.07B — ca6.uscourts.gov
  7. Sixth Circuit Pattern Criminal Jury Instructions, Committee Commentary 14.07B (current through May 29, 2026) — ca6.uscourts.gov
  8. 28 USC 41 — govinfo.gov
  9. Sixth Circuit Pattern Criminal Jury Instructions, Committee Commentary 14.05, quoting United States v Pennell, 737 F.2d 521, 536 (6th Cir. 1984) — ca6.uscourts.gov
  10. Sixth Circuit Pattern Criminal Jury Instructions, Inst. 14.05(3)(B)(2)–(4) — ca6.uscourts.gov
  11. 21 USC 841(b)(1)(A) — govinfo.gov
  12. 21 USC 841(b)(1)(B) — govinfo.gov
  13. Alleyne v United States, No. 11-9335 (US 17 June 2013) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  14. U.S. Sentencing Guidelines Manual §2D1.1(a), (b)(1), (b)(17), (c) & comment. (n.8) (2026) — ussc.gov
  15. 18 USC 3553(f)(4)–(5) and concluding sentence — govinfo.gov
  16. MCL 750.157a(a) — Michigan Legislature
  17. People v Carter, 415 Mich 558, 568–569 (1982) — Michigan Courts
  18. People v Mass, 464 Mich 615 (2001); People v Justice (After Remand), 454 Mich 334, 349 (1997) — Caselaw Access Project
  19. People v Weathersby, 204 Mich App 98, 107 (1994); People v Betancourt, 120 Mich App 58, 65 (1982) — Michigan Courts
  20. People v Carter, 415 Mich 558, 568 (1982); People v Anderson, 418 Mich 31, 35 (1983); People v Williams, 240 Mich App 316, 325 (2000) — Michigan Courts
  21. People v Cotton, 191 Mich App 377, 393 (1991) — Michigan Courts
  22. People v Mass, 464 Mich 615, 632 (2001); People v Denio, 454 Mich 691, 695–696 (1997); People v Carter, 415 Mich 558, 579–582 (1982) — Michigan Courts
  23. 18 USC 3553(f) — govinfo.gov

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.