SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Sentencing

Habitual Offender Enhancement in Michigan Weapons Cases

Key points

  • With one prior felony, the maximum for a new felony punishable by less than life may be raised to 1½ times the normal maximum.[1]
  • With two or more priors the maximum may be doubled, and with three or more it may reach life for a new felony punishable by 5 years or more.[2][3]
  • A fourth-offense defendant whose new felony is a listed "serious crime" and who has a "listed prior felony" faces a minimum of at least 25 years.[4]
  • To seek the enhancement, the prosecutor must file a written notice listing the priors within 21 days after the arraignment on the information.[5][6]
  • The judge, not a jury, decides whether the prior convictions exist.[7]

Michigan's habitual-offender statutes allow a higher maximum sentence for a person who commits a felony after one or more earlier felony convictions.[1][2][3] They apply only when the new offense is itself a felony, and for these statutes a "felony" includes a two-year misdemeanor.[8] Prior convictions count whether they happened in Michigan or elsewhere, as long as they would have been felonies or attempted felonies if obtained in Michigan.[9] This page explains the three levels, the 25-year minimum, how the prosecutor gives notice, and how the enhancement interacts with felony firearm and the guidelines. It does not predict any sentence.

Second, third and fourth offense: the higher maximums

Prior felony convictionsEffect on the new felony
One (second offense)Probation, or a maximum of up to 1½ times the longest term for a first conviction, if the new felony is punishable by less than life[1]
Two or more (third offense)A maximum of up to twice the longest term for a first conviction, if the new felony is punishable by less than life[2]
Three or more (fourth offense), new felony with a maximum of 5 years or moreUp to life or a lesser term[3]
Three or more (fourth offense), new felony with a maximum under 5 yearsA maximum of up to 15 years[3]

Each of these sentencing provisions applies "except as otherwise provided in this section or section 1 of chapter XI," and the second-offense provision is the one that expressly mentions probation.[10] The probation page covers probation in weapons cases.

Applying those multipliers to a common weapons charge shows how the ceiling moves. Carrying a concealed weapon and felon in possession each carry a 5-year maximum.[11] With one prior, the statute allows a maximum of up to 1½ times that, or 7½ years; with two or more, up to twice, or 10 years; and with three or more, because the offense is punishable by 5 years, up to life.[1][2][3] Transporting or possessing a loaded firearm other than a pistol in or upon a vehicle is a misdemeanor punishable by up to 2 years, which counts as a felony for the habitual-offender statutes; its fourth-offense maximum is capped at 15 years.[12][8][3] These are the maximums the statute allows, not the sentence a court will impose. The penalties chart lists the base maximums for other weapons offenses.

When a habitual offender is sentenced to prison for a term of years, the court fixes both a minimum and a maximum, the sentence is indeterminate, and the court may not set a maximum lower than the maximum term for a first conviction of the offense.[13]

The 25-year minimum for some fourth offenders

One part of the fourth-offense statute sets a mandatory floor. If the new felony is a "serious crime" or a conspiracy to commit one, and one or more of the prior felonies is a "listed prior felony," the court must impose a minimum of not less than 25 years.[4] Only one conviction arising out of the same transaction counts as a prior felony for this purpose.[4]

  • Serious crimes are offenses against a person, including assault with intent to murder (750.83), assault with intent to do great bodily harm (750.84), second-degree murder (750.317) and armed robbery (750.529).[14]
  • Listed prior felonies include carrying a firearm with unlawful intent (750.226), carrying a concealed weapon (750.227), discharging a firearm from a vehicle (750.234a), discharging at or in a dwelling or potentially occupied structure (750.234b), discharging at an emergency or police vehicle (750.234c), and a second or later felony firearm conviction (750.227b).[15]

So a weapons-possession conviction can supply the "listed prior felony," but the new charge must itself be one of the listed serious crimes for the 25-year minimum to apply.[4][15][14] A mandatory minimum imposed under a statute is not a departure from the sentencing guidelines.[16]

The notice: 21 days after arraignment on the information

The prosecutor seeks an enhanced sentence by filing a written notice of intent within 21 days after the defendant's arraignment on the information charging the offense or, if arraignment is waived, within 21 days after the information is filed.[5] The notice must list the prior convictions that will or may be relied on, be filed with the court, and be served on the defendant or the defendant's lawyer within that time.[6] If the defendant pleads guilty or no contest at the arraignment on the information, the notice may be filed after that plea.[6]

The stages of a weapons case, from district court to circuit court, are set out on the court process page.

Proving and challenging the prior convictions

The existence of prior convictions is decided by the judge, without a jury, at sentencing or at a separate hearing before sentencing.[7] Any relevant evidence may be used, including a copy of a judgment of conviction, a transcript of a prior trial, plea or sentencing, a court register of actions, information in a presentence report, or a statement of the defendant.[17]

A defendant may challenge the accuracy or constitutional validity of a listed prior by filing a written motion and serving it on the prosecutor.[18] The defendant must first make a prima facie showing that the prior is inaccurate or constitutionally invalid; the prosecutor then bears the burden of proving it by a preponderance of the evidence.[18]

Practical points when a notice is filed:

  • Check each listed conviction against the court records: the date, the court, the offense and whether it was a felony.[6][17]
  • Note convictions from other states, which count only if they would have been felonies or attempted felonies in Michigan.[9]
  • For the 25-year minimum, check whether two listed priors came from the same transaction.[4]

Effect on the guidelines and on parole

For a habitual offender, the guidelines are scored on the new offense and the top of the recommended minimum range is increased by 25% for a second felony, 50% for a third and 100% for a fourth or later.[19] The sentencing guidelines page explains the scoring.

A person sentenced as a habitual offender, other than for a major controlled substance offense, is not eligible for parole until the minimum term set by the judge expires, unless the sentencing judge or a successor gives written approval for parole at an earlier date authorized by law.[20] That exception does not apply to prisoners subject to disciplinary time.[20]

Felony firearm and habitual status

  • The general habitual-offender enhancement is not applied to a felony firearm sentence, because that statute has its own 2-, 5- and 10-year scheme (People v Honeycutt, 1987).[21]
  • A prior felony firearm conviction does count as a prior felony later: in People v Gardner (2008) the Michigan Supreme Court upheld third-offense habitual status where the two priors, felonious assault and felony firearm, came from one incident.[22]
  • Using the same prior felony to establish felony firearm and habitual status does not violate double jeopardy (People v Phillips, 1996).[23]

The felony firearm sentencing page has more on that offense. Felon in possession is a common weapons charge for people with priors, and its elements are explained on the felon in possession page.

Juvenile sentences and pleas

In People v Jones (2012) the Court of Appeals held that an adult-court conviction that resulted in a juvenile sentence still counts as a prior conviction for third-offense habitual sentencing, because MCL 769.11 looks at whether the person was convicted, not at the sentence.[24] The juvenile gun charges page covers cases involving minors.

In a felony case, before accepting a guilty or no-contest plea, the judge must advise the defendant of the maximum possible prison sentence and any mandatory minimum sentence required by law.[25] The plea agreements page explains how plea agreements work in weapons cases.

Federal law has its own repeat-offender enhancement for felon in possession, the Armed Career Criminal Act, covered on the ACCA page. The drug crimes guide covers federal drug charges, which can involve the same priors.

Common questions

What is a habitual offender in Michigan?

It is a sentencing status, not a separate crime. A person convicted of a new felony who has one or more prior felony or attempted felony convictions, from Michigan or convictions that would have been felonies in Michigan, may receive a higher maximum sentence.[9] The possible increase depends on the number of priors: up to 1½ times the maximum for one, up to twice for two, and up to life or 15 years for three or more.[1][2][3]

How long does the prosecutor have to file a habitual offender notice?

The prosecutor must file a written notice of intent within 21 days after the defendant's arraignment on the information or, if arraignment is waived, within 21 days after the information is filed.[5] The notice must list the prior convictions that will or may be relied on and must be served on the defendant or the defendant's lawyer.[6]

Can a prior conviction listed in the habitual notice be challenged?

Yes. A defendant may challenge the accuracy or constitutional validity of a listed prior by a written motion served on the prosecutor.[18] Once the defendant makes a prima facie showing that a prior is inaccurate or invalid, the prosecutor must prove it by a preponderance of the evidence.[18] The judge decides the issue without a jury, at sentencing or at a separate hearing.[7]

Does carrying a concealed weapon count toward the 25-year minimum?

Carrying a concealed weapon (750.227) can count as a "listed prior felony," as can carrying with unlawful intent and several discharge offenses.[15][26] The 25-year minimum applies only if the new felony is a listed "serious crime," a list of offenses against a person such as assault with intent to do great bodily harm and armed robbery.[4][14]

Can habitual offender status be added to a felony firearm sentence?

No. Because the felony firearm statute has its own escalating terms for repeat convictions, the Court of Appeals held in People v Honeycutt (1987) that applying the general habitual-offender provisions to it is improper.[21] A felony firearm conviction does count as a prior felony in a later case.[22]

Sources

  1. MCL 769.10(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCL 769.11(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  3. MCL 769.12(1)(b), MCL 769.12(1)(c) — Michigan Legislature
  4. MCL 769.12(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  5. MCL 769.13(1), MCL 769.13(2) — Michigan Legislature
  6. MCL 769.13(2), (3) — Michigan Legislature
  7. MCL 769.13(4)-(6) — Michigan Legislature
  8. People v Washington, 501 Mich 342, 357 (2018); People v Smith, 423 Mich 427, 434 (1985); People v Urbanski, 348 Mich App 90, 114 (2023); CRIMBB vol 2 §4.2, nn 9-10 — Michigan Courts
  9. MCL 769.10(1); MCL 769.11(1); MCL 769.12(1) — Michigan Legislature
  10. MCL 769.10(1)(a); MCL 769.11(1)(a); MCL 769.12(1)(b)–(c) — Michigan Legislature
  11. MCL 777.16m — Michigan Legislature
  12. MCL 750.227c — Michigan Legislature
  13. MCL 769.10(2); MCL 769.11(2); MCL 769.12(2) — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCL 769.12(6)(c) — Michigan Legislature
  15. MCL 769.12(6)(a)(iii), MCL 769.12(6)(a)(iv) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 769.34(2), (2)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCL 769.13(5) — Michigan Legislature
  18. MCL 769.13(4), (6) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 777.21(3) — Michigan Legislature
  20. MCL 769.12(4) — Michigan Legislature
  21. People v Honeycutt, 163 Mich App 757, 762 (1987) — Michigan Courts
  22. People v Gardner, 482 Mich 41, 44, 49-50 (2008) — Michigan Courts
  23. People v Phillips, 219 Mich App 159, 162-163 (1996) — Michigan Courts
  24. People v Jones, 297 Mich App 80, 85-86 (2012) — Michigan Courts
  25. MCR 6.302(B)(2) — Michigan Courts
  26. MCL 769.12(6)(a)(iii)–(iv), (6)(c) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.