Key points
- A traffic stop is permissible when an officer has reasonable suspicion that the person stopped is breaking the law, and the officer's actual motive does not decide whether the stop was reasonable.[1]
- A stop that lasts longer than needed to handle the violation is an unreasonable seizure unless the stop produces new reasonable suspicion of crime.[2]
- In People v Kavanaugh (2017), holding a driver after the stop was complete to wait for a drug-sniffing dog was an unconstitutional seizure, and its fruits should not have been admitted.[3]
- Consent to search given during a lawful stop, whose questions did not exceed its scope or unreasonably extend it, is valid without separate suspicion of drug activity.[4]
- Passengers are seized during a traffic stop too, and may challenge the stop's constitutionality.[5]
Police in Michigan may stop a car when an officer has reasonable suspicion that the person stopped is breaking the law.[1] The stop may last only as long as needed to handle the reason for it, unless the stop itself turns up new reasonable suspicion of a crime.[2][4]
A drug investigation can begin with an ordinary traffic stop. This page covers the rules for the stop itself: the suspicion needed, how long it may last, questions and consent, passengers, and pat-downs. What happens when police search the car, bring a dog, or say they smell marijuana is covered in the vehicle search guide, the drug dog guide and the marijuana odor guide.
What police need to stop a car
A traffic stop seizes the driver and any passengers.[5] A stop is permissible when the officer has reasonable suspicion, meaning a particularized and objective basis for suspecting the person stopped of breaking the law.[1] The same standard governs any brief investigatory (Terry) stop: an officer must have more than an unparticularized suspicion or hunch, and the suspicion must be objectively reasonable and focused on the specific person.[6]
The officer's real reason for making the stop does not matter if the legal basis exists. The constitutional reasonableness of a traffic stop does not depend on the actual motivations of the officers involved.[1]
Officers can make reasonable mistakes. Reasonable suspicion can rest on an objectively reasonable mistake about the scope of a law, but the Michigan Supreme Court held in People v Lucynski (2022) that misunderstanding an unambiguous statute is not a reasonable mistake of law and that such mistakes occur only in exceedingly rare cases involving ambiguous statutes.[7] In a later 2024 decision in the same case, the Court stated that a seizure based on an officer's unreasonable interpretation of the law warrants application of the exclusionary rule.[8]
Some facts are not enough on their own. In People v Prude (2024), the Michigan Supreme Court held that mere presence in an area of frequent criminal activity does not give particularized suspicion, that an officer may not detain someone simply for declining to identify themselves, and that refusal to cooperate, without more, does not justify a detention.[9]
How long a stop may last
A traffic stop is reasonable while the driver is held only so the officer can ask reasonable questions about the violation and its context for a reasonable period.[4] Michigan courts treat a computer check of the driver through the Law Enforcement Information Network (LEIN) as a routine and accepted part of a stop, and in People v Davis (2002) the time taken to run one did not unreasonably extend the stop.[10]
The U.S. Supreme Court has said that a stop normally ends when police have no further need to control the scene and tell the driver and passengers they are free to leave.[11] A stop that lasts longer than needed to handle the matter for which it was made violates the Constitution.[2] Officers may do unrelated checks during a lawful stop, but not in a way that prolongs it, unless they have the reasonable suspicion ordinarily needed to detain someone.[2]
People v Kavanaugh (2017) applied that rule to a drug dog. The stop was complete once the officer confirmed who owned the car, gave a warning and said no ticket would issue; holding the driver after that to wait for a drug-sniffing dog and its handler was an unconstitutional seizure, and the fruits of that seizure should not have been admitted.[3] The Court of Appeals also said that dash-camera video should, whenever practicable, be provided to and reviewed by the court.[3]
What people get wrong: police cannot hold a car "as long as it takes" for a dog to arrive. A dog sniff during a lawful stop that is not prolonged generally does not violate the Fourth Amendment, but a completed stop may not be extended for a dog without new reasonable suspicion.[12][13][2][3]
Questions during a stop
Officers may ask questions unrelated to the reason for the stop, and those questions do not make the stop unlawful so long as they do not measurably extend it.[11] If a stop reveals a new set of circumstances, the officer may extend the detention long enough to resolve the suspicion raised.[4]
In People v Campbell (2019), the Court of Appeals held that an officer may ask a lawfully detained person about weapons in the vehicle, because the question relates to conducting the stop safely.[14] A follow-up question that was not strictly related to the stop did not make it unconstitutional because it did not unreasonably prolong the stop, and the answers then gave probable cause to extend it.[14]
Whether statements made during a stop can be used is a separate question governed by Miranda and voluntariness rules, explained in the Miranda guide.
Consent given during a stop
In People v Williams (2005), the Michigan Supreme Court held that where the stop was justified and the officer's questions did not exceed its scope or unreasonably extend it, the driver's consent to search the car was valid, with no need for separate suspicion of drug activity.[4] Consent still has limits. In People v Mead (2019), a driver lacked authority to consent to a search of a passenger's backpack that the passenger had been holding in his lap.[15] How courts judge whether consent was voluntary, and its scope, is covered in the consent search guide.
Passengers
When police stop a car, passengers are seized as well as the driver and may challenge the constitutionality of the stop.[5] A passenger does not lose the ability to challenge a later search of the vehicle merely because the stop itself was legal.[5]
In People v Lyons (2025), the Court of Appeals held that officers may order a passenger to remain in the vehicle for officer safety, starting from the moment the stop is initiated, and that the passenger's refusal to follow that lawful order led to a lawful arrest and search.[16]
Exit orders, pat-downs and protective searches
During a stop, officers may order the driver and passengers out of the car.[17] They may pat down a driver or passenger only on reasonable suspicion that the person is armed and dangerous, and they may make a protective search of the passenger compartment for weapons only on reasonable suspicion that an occupant is dangerous and could get immediate control of a weapon.[17] The protective search is limited to the areas where a weapon could be placed or hidden.[17]
A pat-down is for weapons only. The officer may seize contraband felt during a lawful pat-down only if there is probable cause that the object is contraband, meaning its character is immediately apparent.[18]
Where the stop leads next
Once a car is stopped, other rules decide whether it may be searched. A search under the automobile exception needs probable cause that the car contains contraband or evidence of a crime.[19] Since People v Armstrong (2025), the smell of marijuana alone is no longer probable cause to search a car.[20] The Michigan Supreme Court in Armstrong expressly left undecided whether reasonable suspicion of a civil infraction, rather than a crime, can support a Terry stop.[21] In People v Wilkins (2026), the Court held that probable cause of only a civil marijuana infraction does not allow a car search under the automobile exception; Michigan has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review Wilkins (No. 26-540), and as of 17 November 2026 the docket showed no ruling, so the law in this area may change.[22][23] The marijuana odor guide has the details.
The drunk-driving guide covers stops for suspected impaired driving in detail, including reasonable suspicion for a traffic stop and what happens at an OWI stop. For drugs and driving specifically, see drugs and driving in Michigan. If evidence from a stop is challenged, the motion to suppress guide explains the process.
Common questions
Can police stop a car for a minor violation because they suspect drugs?
The constitutional reasonableness of a traffic stop does not depend on the actual motivations of the officers involved.[1] What matters is whether the officer had reasonable suspicion, meaning a particularized and objective basis for suspecting the person stopped of breaking the law.[1] An objectively reasonable mistake about what the law prohibits can still support a stop, but misreading an unambiguous statute cannot.[7]
Can police make a driver wait at the roadside for a drug dog?
Not by extending the stop without new suspicion. Officers may do unrelated checks during a lawful stop only if they do not prolong it, unless reasonable suspicion of crime develops.[2] In People v Kavanaugh (2017), holding a driver after the stop was complete to wait for a dog was an unconstitutional seizure.[3] A dog sniff during a lawful stop that is not prolonged generally does not violate the Fourth Amendment.[12][13]
Can an officer ask about drugs during a traffic stop?
Questions unrelated to the reason for the stop do not make the stop unlawful so long as they do not measurably extend it.[11] A stop is reasonable while the driver is held to answer reasonable questions about the violation and its context for a reasonable time, and it may be extended if new circumstances raise suspicion.[4] Questions about weapons are treated as related to doing the stop safely.[14]
Can a passenger challenge a traffic stop that led to a drug charge?
Yes. When police stop a car, passengers as well as the driver are seized and may challenge the constitutionality of the stop.[5] A passenger also does not lose the ability to challenge a later search merely because the stop itself was legal.[5] Whether a passenger can challenge the search of a particular place in the car depends on the passenger's own expectation of privacy, explained in the vehicle search guide.[24]
Can police pat down a driver or passenger during a traffic stop?
Only on reasonable suspicion that the person is armed and dangerous.[17] A pat-down is limited to finding weapons, and an officer may seize contraband felt during it only if there is probable cause that the object is contraband, meaning its character is immediately apparent.[18] Officers may also order the driver and passengers out of the car during a stop.[17]
Sources
- Whren v United States, 517 US 806, 813 (1996); Heien v North Carolina, 574 US 54, 60 (2014) — Michigan Courts
- Rodriguez v United States, 575 US 348, 350, 355 (2015); People v Kavanaugh, 320 Mich App 293, 300–301 (2017); Illinois v Caballes, 543 US 405, 407 (2005) — Michigan Courts
- People v Kavanaugh, 320 Mich App 293, 300–309 & n 8 (2017) — Michigan Courts
- People v Williams, 472 Mich 308, 310, 315, 318 (2005) — Michigan Courts
- Brendlin v California, 551 US 249, 251 (2007); People v Mead, 503 Mich 205, 214 (2019) — Michigan Courts
- Terry v Ohio, 392 US 1, 27 (1968); People v Champion, 452 Mich 92, 98 (1996); People v Prude, ___ Mich ___ (2024) — Michigan Courts
- People v Lucynski (Lucynski I), 509 Mich 618, 626-627, 652, 657 (2022); Heien v North Carolina, 574 US 54, 57, 60, 66, 68 (2014) — Michigan Courts
- People v Lucynski (Lucynski III), ___ Mich ___ (2024) — Michigan Courts
- People v Prude, ___ Mich ___ (2024) — Michigan Courts
- People v Simmons, 316 Mich App 322, 327-328 (2016); People v Davis, 250 Mich App 357, 366-368 (2002) — Michigan Courts
- Arizona v Johnson, 555 US 323, 333-334 (2009) — Michigan Courts
- Illinois v Caballes, 543 US 405, 409-410 (2005) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- Illinois v Caballes, 543 US 405, 407 (2005); Rodriguez v United States, 575 US 348, 350 (2015) — Michigan Courts
- People v Campbell, 329 Mich App 185, 199-200 (2019) — Michigan Courts
- People v Mead, 503 Mich 205, 214–219 & n 3 (2019) — Michigan Courts
- People v Lyons, ___ Mich App ___ (2025); People v Corr, 287 Mich App 499, 507-508 (2010) — Michigan Courts
- Knowles v Iowa, 525 US 113, 117–118 (1998); Michigan v Long, 463 US 1032, 1049 (1983); Arizona v Johnson, 555 US 323, 327 (2009) — Michigan Courts
- People v Custer, 465 Mich 319, 328 (2001); People v Champion, 452 Mich 92, 99–101 (1996); Arizona v Johnson, 555 US 323, 327 (2009) — Michigan Courts
- Carroll v United States, 267 US 132 (1925); People v Levine, 461 Mich 172, 178–179 (1999); People v Carter, 250 Mich App 510, 516 (2002); Collins v Virginia, 584 US 586, 594, 601 (2018) — Michigan Courts
- People v Armstrong, ___ Mich ___ (2025) (Docket No. 165233), slip op at 1–2, 12, 14; overruling the rule of People v Kazmierczak, 461 Mich 411 (2000) — Michigan Courts
- People v Armstrong, ___ Mich ___ (2025), slip op at 14 n 11, 15 n 13 — Michigan Courts
- People v Wilkins, ___ Mich ___ (2026) (Docket No. 167737), slip op at 2, 5, 11, 18 — Michigan Courts
- Michigan v Wilkins, US Supreme Court Docket No. 26-540 — Supreme Court of the United States
- People v Mead, 503 Mich 205, 213-215 (2019) — Michigan Courts
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.