SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Searches, stops and arrest

Can Police Search Because They Smell Marijuana? Michigan After People v Armstrong

Key points

  • On April 2, 2025, the Michigan Supreme Court held in People v Armstrong that the smell of marijuana, standing alone, no longer establishes probable cause to search a vehicle.[1]
  • The smell may still be one factor in the totality of the circumstances; facts showing the where, when and who of illegal use are critical.[2]
  • On July 22, 2026, in People v Wilkins, the Court held that probable cause of only a civil marijuana infraction does not allow a warrantless car search; police need probable cause of a criminal amount or another crime.[3][4]
  • Michigan has petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to review Wilkins; as of 17 November 2026 the docket showed no ruling on the petition, so the law described here may change.[5]
  • Armstrong left open whether burnt and unburnt marijuana smell should be treated differently, and whether suspicion of a civil infraction can support a Terry stop.[6]

No. Since People v Armstrong, decided April 2, 2025, the smell of marijuana standing alone no longer establishes probable cause to search a car in Michigan.[1] The smell can still be one factor among others, and on July 22, 2026, People v Wilkins added that a warrantless car search under the automobile exception needs probable cause of a criminal amount of marijuana or another crime, not merely of a civil infraction.[2][4]

A common belief is that the odor of marijuana alone lets police search a car. That has not been Michigan law since Armstrong.[1] This page explains what changed, what the two decisions held, the U.S. Supreme Court petition now pending in Wilkins, and the questions the courts have left open. It states the law as of November 2026.

The old rule and why it changed

In People v Kazmierczak (2000), the Michigan Supreme Court had held that the smell of marijuana alone was enough for probable cause to search a vehicle under the automobile exception.[1] Then Michigan voters adopted the Michigan Regulation and Taxation of Marihuana Act (MRTMA), which took effect December 6, 2018.[7]

The MRTMA says that, except as its section 4 provides, conduct it permits for adults 21 and older, including possessing up to 2.5 ounces of marijuana (no more than 15 grams as concentrate) and, at home, keeping up to 10 ounces and growing up to 12 plants, is not grounds for arrest, prosecution, seizing property, or "search or inspection."[8][9][10][11][12] The MRTMA does not cover anyone under 21.[13]

People v Armstrong (2025)

Armstrong began on October 8, 2020, when Detroit officers doing parole compliance checks approached a parked Jeep after one officer said she smelled burnt marijuana coming from it; a handgun was found under the front passenger seat.[14] The trial court found, based on body-camera video, that the gun was discovered by searching the car rather than seen in plain view, suppressed it, and dismissed the case.[14]

The Michigan Supreme Court affirmed. It held that Kazmierczak's rule "is no longer viable in light of the enactment of the MRTMA" and that "the smell of marijuana, standing alone, no longer constitutes probable cause sufficient to support a search for contraband."[1] Assuming without deciding that the smell gave reasonable suspicion for an investigatory stop, the Court found no clear error in the finding that the gun was not in plain view.[14] Justice Cavanagh wrote for five justices, Justice Zahra dissented, and Justice Thomas did not take part.[14]

The Court gave reasons. After the MRTMA, the smell of marijuana "might just as likely indicate that the person is in possession of a legal amount of marijuana, recently used marijuana legally, or was simply in the presence of someone else who used marijuana."[15] And unlike the smell of alcohol, the Court said, the smell of marijuana is not particularly probative of who is using it or how recently it was used.[15]

Smell as one factor: "the where, when, and who"

Armstrong did not make the smell irrelevant. The smell of marijuana "may be a factor, but not a stand-alone one," in deciding whether the totality of the circumstances established probable cause for a warrantless vehicle search.[2] Other relevant facts might include an officer's observation of signs of intoxication or the presence of smoke, and facts showing "the where, when, and who" of illegal use are critical.[2]

When police search without a warrant, it is the prosecutor's burden to justify the search.[16]

People v Wilkins (2026): civil infractions are not enough

Wilkins arose from a Michigan State Police stop for speeding on January 16, 2023. The trooper smelled marijuana, saw none in plain view, saw no signs that anyone was intoxicated or smoking, and learned that both occupants were under 21; after the passenger said she had "some shake," he searched the car and found a loaded pistol and empty ziplock packages in a backpack.[17] The driver was charged with carrying a concealed weapon in a vehicle.[17]

The Michigan Supreme Court held that where the trooper had probable cause to believe only that a civil infraction occurred, the search was not permitted under the automobile exception, because a civil infraction is not a crime and substances prohibited only by civil law are not "contraband" for this purpose.[3] Because the amount of marijuana separates a civil infraction from a crime, the officer needs probable cause to believe a criminal amount is present, and merely smelling marijuana does not supply that.[4] The passenger's statement that she may have had a small amount did not either.[4]

Justice Thomas wrote for five justices; Justice Welch also wrote that she would have decided the case under the Michigan Constitution, and Justice Zahra, joined by Justice Bernstein, dissented.[17] The majority relied on the Fourth Amendment and did not decide whether the Michigan Constitution gives more protection.[17] The case was sent back to the Kent Circuit Court.[17]

Which amounts are civil and which are criminal

Wilkins pointed to the MRTMA's penalty section, MCL 333.27965, as the place where the amount of marijuana separates a civil infraction from a crime.[4] The table summarizes it; the possession limits guide and the under-21 guide have the detail.

SituationClassification under the MRTMA
Under 21, first violation, up to 2.5 ounces or 12 plantsCivil infraction: ages 18 to 20, a fine up to $100 and forfeiture; under 18, a fine up to $100 or community service, forfeiture, and 4 hours of drug education or counseling.[18][19]
No more than the legal amount, but not otherwise authorized by the actCivil infraction, fine up to $100 and forfeiture, except for listed conduct such as impaired driving or possession on school grounds.[20][21][22]
More than the legal amount, up to twice itCivil infraction for a first violation (fine up to $500) or second (up to $1,000); a third or later violation is a misdemeanor with a fine up to $2,000.[23]
More than twice the legal amountMisdemeanor, with no jail unless the violation was habitual, willful and for a commercial purpose, or involved violence.[24]

The two tiers for more than the legal amount do not apply to a person who engaged in conduct that section 4 of the act does not authorize, such as driving under the influence of marijuana.[25][26][21]

What Wilkins did not change

The Court said nothing in its opinion affects the police power to search for evidence of criminal violations; with probable cause, an officer may search a car for evidence of driving under the influence of marijuana or of distributing criminal quantities.[27] It added that if the trooper had seen a criminal amount in plain view, the driver smoking, dissipating smoke, or signs of intoxication, the smell combined with any of those may well have established probable cause.[27] The MRTMA itself does not authorize driving under the influence of marijuana, consuming it while driving, or smoking it in the passenger area of a vehicle on a public road.[21]

The pending U.S. Supreme Court petition

The State of Michigan has petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court for review in Michigan v Wilkins, No. 26-540; the petition was filed October 20, 2026, the response is due November 23, 2026, and as of 17 November 2026 the docket showed no ruling on it.[5] If the Court grants review, it could change or reverse the Wilkins rule, so the law described on this page may change.

Questions the courts have left open

  • Burnt versus unburnt smell: Armstrong concerned burnt marijuana but declined to draw a distinction between burnt and unburnt smell.[6]
  • Stops for civil infractions: Armstrong expressly left for another day whether reasonable suspicion of a civil infraction, rather than a crime, can support a Terry stop.[6]
  • Drug dogs trained on marijuana: both cases concerned what an officer said he or she smelled, and the drug dog guide explains why dog alerts remain an open question.[14][17]
  • Trash and home warrants: in People v Keller (2007), marijuana found in trash supported a warrant for a home, a decision that came before the MRTMA took effect in 2018.[28][7] The sources this guide relies on do not say whether that reasoning still holds for lawful amounts.

Medical marijuana cardholders

Michigan's medical marijuana law has its own rule. Having or applying for a registry identification card is not probable cause or reasonable suspicion and may not be used to support a search of the person or the person's property.[29] The medical marijuana immunity guide explains the protections cardholders have and their limits.

What to read next

The broader rules for car searches, including containers, arrests and inventories, are in the vehicle search guide. Marijuana and driving is covered in drugs and driving in Michigan and in the drunk-driving guide's page on marijuana and driving.

Common questions

Can police search a car in Michigan just because they smell marijuana?

No. In People v Armstrong (2025), the Michigan Supreme Court held that the smell of marijuana, standing alone, no longer constitutes probable cause to search a vehicle.[1] The smell can still count as one factor alongside others, such as signs of intoxication or the presence of smoke, when a court decides whether the totality of the circumstances amounted to probable cause.[2]

Does it matter whether the smell was burnt or fresh marijuana?

That question is open. Armstrong involved the alleged smell of burnt marijuana, but the Court expressly declined to draw a further distinction between the smell of burnt and unburnt marijuana.[6] In Wilkins, the trooper said it did not smell like the driver had just smoked, and the Court held the smell did not supply probable cause of a criminal amount.[17][4]

What did People v Wilkins decide?

Wilkins, decided July 22, 2026, held that the automobile exception does not allow a warrantless car search when police have probable cause of only a civil infraction, there possession of a small amount of marijuana by people under 21.[3] Officers need probable cause of a criminal amount of marijuana or another crime, and neither the smell nor a passenger's admission to a small amount was enough.[4]

Can police still search if they see marijuana or signs of impairment?

Possibly. Wilkins said that, with probable cause, officers may still search a car for evidence of driving under the influence of marijuana or of distributing criminal quantities.[27] It also said that the smell combined with a criminal amount in plain view, the driver smoking, dissipating smoke, or signs of intoxication may well establish probable cause.[27]

Can a medical marijuana card be a reason to search someone?

No. Under the Michigan Medical Marihuana Act, having or applying for a registry identification card is not probable cause or reasonable suspicion and may not be used to support a search of the person or the person's property.[29] Applications and the list of cardholders are confidential, and the state verifies to police whether a card is valid without disclosing more than is reasonably necessary to do so.[29]

Sources

  1. People v Armstrong, ___ Mich ___ (2025) (Docket No. 165233), slip op at 1–2, 12, 14; overruling the rule of People v Kazmierczak, 461 Mich 411 (2000) — Michigan Courts
  2. People v Armstrong, ___ Mich ___ (2025), slip op at 13–14 — Michigan Courts
  3. People v Wilkins, ___ Mich ___ (2026) (Docket No. 167737), slip op at 2, 5, 11, 18 — Michigan Courts
  4. People v Wilkins, ___ Mich ___ (2026), slip op at 22–24 — Michigan Courts
  5. Michigan v Wilkins, US Supreme Court Docket No. 26-540 — Supreme Court of the United States
  6. People v Armstrong, ___ Mich ___ (2025), slip op at 14 n 11, 15 n 13 — Michigan Courts
  7. MCL 333.27951; 2018 Initiated Law 1 — Michigan Legislature
  8. MCL 333.27955(1) (lead-in) — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCL 333.27955(1)(a)–(b) — Michigan Legislature
  10. MCL 333.27955(1) — Michigan Legislature
  11. MCL 333.27955(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  12. MCL 333.27955(1)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  13. MCL 333.27954(1)(b), (c) — Michigan Legislature
  14. People v Armstrong, ___ Mich ___ (2025) (Docket No. 165233), slip op at 2-4, 21; syllabus — Michigan Courts
  15. People v Armstrong, ___ Mich ___ (2025), slip op at 12 & n 10 — Michigan Courts
  16. People v Armstrong, ___ Mich ___ (2025), slip op at 11 — Michigan Courts
  17. People v Wilkins, ___ Mich ___ (2026) (Docket No. 167737), slip op at 1-4 & n 1, 25; id. (Welch, J., concurring), slip op at 1; id. (Zahra, J., dissenting) — Michigan Courts
  18. MCL 333.27965(3) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 333.27965(3)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  20. MCL 333.27965(1) — Michigan Legislature
  21. MCL 333.27954(1)(a), (g) — Michigan Legislature
  22. MCL 333.27954(1)(h) — Michigan Legislature
  23. MCL 333.27965(2) (lead-in and (a)-(c)) — Michigan Legislature
  24. MCL 333.27965(4) — Michigan Legislature
  25. MCL 333.27965(2) (lead-in) — Michigan Legislature
  26. MCL 333.27965(4) (lead-in) — Michigan Legislature
  27. People v Wilkins, ___ Mich ___ (2026), slip op at 18 n 23, 23–24 — Michigan Courts
  28. People v Keller, 479 Mich 467, 477, 483 (2007) — Michigan Courts
  29. MCL 333.26426(g), (h)(1)-(4) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.