Key points
- Since 4 April 2021, Michigan licensing boards, apart from a few listed exceptions, may consider a conviction as evidence of character only if it is a felony that meets one of four tests.[1][2][3]
- Boards licensing child care, nursing homes and adult foster care, the police standards commission and the Board of Law Examiners are not held to those limits.[3]
- A licensed private security guard business may not employ a guard with any felony conviction, or with a conviction in the last 5 years for illegally using, carrying or possessing a dangerous weapon.[4]
- Michigan employers other than law enforcement agencies may not ask about or keep records of a misdemeanor arrest that did not lead to a conviction; a pending felony charge is not covered.[5]
- A set-aside conviction cannot be used as evidence in a negligent hiring or licensing lawsuit.[6]
A weapons conviction can matter long after the sentence ends, but Michigan law limits how much it can count in some settings. Since 4 April 2021, licensing boards other than a few listed ones may treat a conviction as evidence of poor character only if it is a felony with a specific connection to the license or to public safety.[1][2][3] Employers face fewer limits, though Michigan bars employers other than law enforcement agencies from asking about misdemeanor arrests that did not lead to a conviction, and federal law sets rules for background reports.[5][7][8]
This page focuses on what is different for firearm and weapons records; for noncitizens, immigration consequences are covered separately on gun convictions and immigration. General background-check law is covered in the retail fraud guide's page on theft convictions and employment.
Licensing boards: the felony-only rule since 2021
A licensing board "shall not consider an individual's criminal conviction, in and of itself, as conclusive proof" of a lack of good moral character.[3] Under MCL 338.42(2), as amended by 2020 PA 368, a covered board may consider a conviction as evidence only if the record includes a felony and the board finds at least one of the following:[1][2]
- The offense has a direct and specific relationship to the activities the license authorizes.[2]
- The offense involves a demonstrable risk to public safety.[2]
- Because of the license, the person is more likely to commit a later offense than without it.[2]
- A later offense committed with the license's aid would cause greater harm than without it.[2]
The board must also consider any certificate of employability and information about current circumstances, including how long ago the offense occurred, whether the sentence was completed, rehabilitation, testimonials, and employment history and aspirations.[2] If it uses a conviction, it must notify the person, who may rebut the evidence.[2]
Records a board may not use
Under MCL 338.43(1), a licensing board may not use these records:[9]
- An arrest not followed by a conviction.[9]
- A conviction that was reversed or vacated, and the related arrest records.[9]
- An arrest or conviction for a misdemeanor or felony unrelated to the person's likelihood to serve the public in a fair, honest and open manner.[9]
- An arrest or conviction for a misdemeanor that cannot be punished by jail or prison.[9]
Boards that are not held to those limits
Some boards may use any criminal conviction as evidence of character, though still not as conclusive proof: the state agencies licensing child care organizations, homes for the aged or nursing homes, and adult foster care facilities; the Michigan Commission on Law Enforcement Standards, under whose act police officers are licensed or certified; and the Board of Law Examiners.[3][10] The professional licensing effects of other kinds of offenses are covered in the retail fraud guide's page on theft convictions and professional licenses.
Security guard work
Private security work has its own statute. A security guard business license issued after 28 March 2001 requires that the applicant has not been convicted of a felony and was not convicted in the previous 5 years of a listed offense.[11] Employees hired by a licensee after that date must meet the same two conviction standards.[4]
| Record | Effect on licensed security work |
|---|---|
| Any felony conviction | Bars a license issued after 28 March 2001 and employment by a licensee[11][4] |
| Felony or misdemeanor involving illegally using, carrying or possessing a dangerous weapon | Bars a license and employment for the 5 years before the application[11][4] |
| Felony or misdemeanor involving an assault, controlled substances, dishonesty, or two or more alcohol-related offenses | Also on the 5-year list[4] |
Jobs that require carrying a pistol
A concealed pistol license (CPL) may be issued only to someone who "has never been convicted of a felony in this state or elsewhere," a bar that a restoration of gun rights does not lift.[12][13] The ERPO statute recognizes people required to carry a pistol as a condition of employment who hold a CPL, along with police officers, sheriffs, deputies, State Police members, corrections officers and employees, and certain federal officers.[10] If one of them becomes the subject of an extreme risk protection order (ERPO), the clerk notifies the employer.[14] The CPL rules for people with records are on can a restored felon get a CPL, the general requirements on Michigan CPL requirements, and ERPOs on served with an ERPO. Possession itself after a conviction is covered on restoring gun rights in Michigan.
What employers may ask
Under the Elliott-Larsen Civil Rights Act, an employer, employment agency or labor organization may not request, make or keep a record of a misdemeanor arrest, detention or disposition that did not result in a conviction.[15][5] A person is not guilty of perjury for declining to disclose information the section protects.[5] The rule does not cover a felony charge before conviction or dismissal, and it does not apply to law enforcement agencies, including the Department of Corrections.[5] If all charges were dismissed before trial, the arrest record must be removed from the State Police's public ICHAT database.[16]
Background reports under federal law
An employer that uses a consumer reporting company must first give a clear written disclosure, in a document that is only the disclosure, and get written authorization; before taking adverse action based on the report, it must give the person a copy and a written summary of rights.[8] Reporting companies may not include arrest records more than seven years old, or until the statute of limitations expires if longer, but conviction records are outside the seven-year limit.[7] Those limits do not apply to a job with a salary of $75,000 or more.[17]
HYTA and set-asides
Under Michigan law, an assignment to youthful trainee status under the Holmes Youthful Trainee Act (HYTA) "is not a conviction for a crime," and, with a listed exception, the person shall not suffer a civil disability or loss of right or privilege following release from that status because of the assignment.[18] The HYTA program is explained on HYTA for gun charges.
After a set-aside, the person is considered not to have been previously convicted, with exceptions.[19] The State Police's nonpublic record may still be shown to the Department of Corrections or a law enforcement agency when the person applies to work there.[20] A set-aside conviction cannot be used as evidence in a lawsuit for negligent hiring, admission or licensure.[6] Eligibility is covered on setting aside a weapons conviction and the effects on does a set-aside restore gun rights.
Common questions
Can a licensing board deny me because of a misdemeanor weapons conviction?
For boards covered by the 2021 limits, a conviction may be considered as evidence of character only if the record includes a felony that meets one of the four tests.[1][2] Boards also may not use records of a misdemeanor for which a person cannot be jailed.[9] The exempt boards, such as child care licensing and the police standards commission, may use any conviction as evidence.[3]
What does a board have to do before relying on my conviction?
A board must consider any certificate of employability and other information about current circumstances, such as how long ago the offense occurred, whether the sentence was completed, rehabilitation, testimonials and work history.[2] If it uses a conviction against an applicant, it must notify the person, who may rebut it by showing rehabilitation, present ability to serve the public fairly and honestly, or that the legal tests are not met.[2]
Can a background check company report an old weapons conviction?
Under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act, arrest records more than seven years old may not be reported, subject to listed exceptions, but the seven-year limit for other adverse items does not apply to "records of convictions of crimes."[7] The limits also do not apply to a job paying $75,000 a year or more.[17] Under Michigan law a set-aside conviction is treated as if the person had not been previously convicted, with exceptions, and divulging it is restricted, but an entity is not liable for reporting a public record of the conviction that was available as a public record on the date of the report.[19][20]
Do I have to tell an employer about a HYTA case?
Michigan law says a youthful trainee assignment is not a conviction, and the person shall not suffer a civil disability or loss of right or privilege because of it, with one listed exception in the statute.[18] How a specific job application question should be answered is a matter for individual advice.
Will my employer find out about an ERPO?
Only for listed occupations: police officers, sheriffs and deputies, State Police members, corrections officers and employees, federal officers who carry a pistol, and people required to carry a pistol for work who hold a CPL.[10] For those respondents the court clerk notifies the employer, if known, and the statute expresses the intent that the employer work with the union to avoid loss of employment or pay.[14]
Sources
- MCL 338.42(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 338.42(2)(a)–(d), (4), (5) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 338.42(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 338.1067(2); MCL 338.1056(1)(c), (e); MCL 338.1060(1)(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 37.2205a(1)–(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.622(8) — Michigan Legislature
- 15 USC 1681c(a)(2), (a)(5) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- 15 USC 1681b(b)(2)(A), (b)(3)(A) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- MCL 338.43(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 691.1805(5) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 338.1056(1)(c), MCL 338.1056(1)(e); MCL 338.1060(1)(c)(iv); MCL 338.1067(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 28.425b(7)(f) — Michigan Legislature
- *Howard v Mecosta Co Clerk*, 336 Mich App 426 (2021) (Docket No. 353976, decided 11 March 2021) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 691.1811(1); MCL 691.1815(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 37.2205a(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 28.243(8) — Michigan Legislature
- 15 USC 1681c(b)(3) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- MCL 762.14(1), MCL 762.14(2), MCL 762.14(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.622(1), (3), (7), (9) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.623(2)–(6) — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988.