SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Set-aside and restoring firearm rights

Can Someone With a Felony Record Get a CPL in Michigan?

Key points

  • A CPL may be issued only if the applicant has never been convicted of a felony in Michigan or elsewhere and has no felony charge pending.[1]
  • In Howard v Mecosta County Clerk, the Court of Appeals held that a restoration of firearm rights under MCL 28.424 does not alter that bar.[2]
  • For the CPL statute, a Michigan offense expressly designated a misdemeanor is not a felony, and "convicted" includes an accepted guilty or no-contest plea and a juvenile adjudication.[3][4]
  • For a set-aside felony, the only source found is a 2003 Attorney General opinion, and courts are not bound by such opinions.[5][6]
  • A denial can be appealed to the circuit court within 21 days of the decision, and the time limit is jurisdictional.[7][8]

Restoring the right to possess a firearm does not make a person eligible for a concealed pistol license (CPL) in Michigan. A CPL may be issued only if the applicant "has never been convicted of a felony in this state or elsewhere" and has no felony charge pending, and the Court of Appeals has held that a circuit court restoration order does not change that.[1][2] A felony that has been set aside is a less settled question, resting on a 2003 Attorney General opinion rather than a court decision.[5][6]

This page covers people with a felony record. The general CPL rules are on Michigan CPL requirements, and the misdemeanors that bar a CPL for a period of years are on CPL disqualifying misdemeanors.

The "never convicted of a felony" rule

Based solely on the State Police report, the county clerk checks whether the applicant "has never been convicted of a felony in this state or elsewhere, and a felony charge against the applicant is not pending in this state or elsewhere at the time the applicant applies."[1] The statute attaches no waiting period to this condition; it turns on whether the applicant has ever been convicted of a felony.[1]

Two definitions decide who it covers:

  • Felony. For the CPL section, "felony" means a felony under the Code of Criminal Procedure, or a federal or other-state offense designated a felony or punishable by death or more than 1 year in prison; it "does not include a violation of a penal law of this state that is expressly designated as a misdemeanor."[3]
  • Convicted. "Convicted" means a final conviction, the payment of a fine, a guilty or no-contest plea if accepted by the court, a finding of guilt, or a juvenile adjudication or disposition for conduct that would be a crime if committed by an adult.[4]

Because of the juvenile part of that definition, an adjudication for conduct that would be a felony if committed by an adult can count against the felony bar.[4][9] Juvenile cases are covered on juvenile gun charges.

Restored rights and the CPL, by route

How rights came backCPL position
3 years passed after a felony that is not a specified felonyThe Michigan possession ban ended, but the conviction remains, and the CPL rule asks whether the applicant was ever convicted[10][1]
Circuit court order under MCL 28.424 after a specified felonyStill barred, under Howard v Mecosta County Clerk[2]
Conviction set asideA 2003 Attorney General opinion says the felony is not a ground for denial if the person is otherwise qualified; no court ruling found for this guide[5]
Federal relief under 925(c)Removes federal disabilities only; does not extend to state-law disabilities[11]

Howard v Mecosta County Clerk (2021)

In Howard, a man whose firearm rights had been restored by a circuit court under MCL 28.424 sought a CPL.[2] The Court of Appeals concluded that "the plain language of MCL 28.425b(7)(f) prohibits the issuance of a concealed pistol license to a person who has been convicted of a felony" and that this provision "is not altered by MCL 28.424 or MCL 28.426."[2] The court recognized that a person whose rights are restored "now enjoys a number of rights that he had previously lost, such as the right to own and possess a firearm," but a CPL is not among them.[2] The petition process is on petitioning to restore gun rights.

Why the CPL bar matters for federal law

The CPL bar may have a second effect. In In re Schultz, the Court of Appeals noted that one federal court held a Michigan felony continues to count under the federal felon ban even after Michigan restoration, because the CPL bar "triggers the 'unless' clause" in the federal definition of conviction.[12] The Schultz court made "no conclusions in that regard."[12] Federal relief by application to the U.S. Attorney General is covered on federal 925(c) relief.

The set-aside question

A set-aside conviction is treated as if the person had not been previously convicted, with listed exceptions.[13] The Domestic Violence Benchbook quotes a 2003 Attorney General opinion that a person whose felony conviction was set aside under MCL 780.621, "if otherwise qualified, may not be denied a concealed pistol license" on the felony ground.[5] The same benchbook notes that courts "are not bound by Attorney General opinions," and that the opinion "has not been amended" since 2015 PA 3 moved CPL licensing from county gun boards to county clerks.[6] A 2023 Court of Appeals concurrence quoted the Supreme Court's statement that whether such opinions bind other government agencies "is open to question."[14]

The CPL statute also says that information about a disqualifying conviction must not be removed from the Law Enforcement Information Network for CPL purposes, though it may be moved to a separate file used to decide license eligibility.[15] How clerks apply these rules to a set-aside felony is not described in any source verified for this guide. More on set-asides is on does a set-aside restore gun rights.

If the application is denied

  1. The clerk sends a notice of statutory disqualification by first-class mail.[16]
  2. Within 5 business days, the clerk must state in writing each disqualification, the source of each record and its contact information, the right to appeal to the circuit court, and that errors should be taken up with the record's source.[17]
  3. The appeal goes to the circuit court in the circuit where the applicant lives, which reviews the record for error and orders a license issued if the denial was clearly erroneous or arbitrary and capricious.[8]
  4. Under MCR 7.121 and 7.104, the claim of appeal must be filed within 21 days after the decision, and that limit is jurisdictional.[18][7] SCAO form CC 79 is the claim of appeal.[19]

If the denial was arbitrary and capricious, the court must order costs and attorney fees paid to the applicant; if the appeal was frivolous, the applicant must pay the other side's costs and fees.[20] The appeal process is explained on appealing a CPL denial, and the form is on the SCAO CC 79 claim of appeal.[19]

Common questions

My gun rights came back automatically after 3 years. Can I get a CPL now?

The CPL statute asks whether the applicant "has never been convicted of a felony in this state or elsewhere."[1] The 3-year rule ends the Michigan possession ban for a felony that is not a specified felony, but it does not change the fact of the conviction.[10] In Howard v Mecosta County Clerk, the Court of Appeals read the CPL bar by its "plain language" as covering anyone convicted of a felony.[2]

Does a juvenile adjudication count against a CPL application?

Yes, it can. The CPL statute defines "convicted" to include "a juvenile adjudication or disposition" by the family division of circuit court for conduct that would be a crime if committed by an adult.[4] Read with the felony bar, an adjudication for conduct that would be a felony if committed by an adult can count as a felony conviction for CPL purposes.[1][9] Juvenile set-asides are a separate question.

Is a Michigan two-year misdemeanor a felony for CPL purposes?

The CPL section defines "felony" to exclude "a violation of a penal law of this state that is expressly designated as a misdemeanor."[3] Federal and other-state offenses count as felonies there if designated felonies or punishable by more than 1 year.[3] Some misdemeanors still affect CPL eligibility for a period of time under separate rules, which are covered on the disqualifying misdemeanors page.

If my felony is set aside, will the clerk issue a CPL?

A 2003 Attorney General opinion stated that a person whose felony was set aside, if otherwise qualified, may not be denied a CPL on the felony ground.[5] Courts are not bound by such opinions, the Supreme Court, as quoted in a 2023 Court of Appeals concurrence, has called their effect on agencies "open to question," and the benchbook notes the opinion was never updated after clerks took over licensing in 2015.[6][14] No court decision on the point was found.

What if I think the denial is wrong?

The clerk must tell a denied applicant in writing, within 5 business days of the notice of disqualification, each disqualification, the source of each record and how to contact it, and the right to appeal.[17] The appeal goes to the circuit court where the applicant lives, which reviews the record for error.[8] Under the court rules it must be filed within 21 days of the decision.[7]

Sources

  1. MCL 28.425b(7)(f) — Michigan Legislature
  2. *Howard v Mecosta Co Clerk*, 336 Mich App 426 (2021) (Docket No. 353976, decided 11 March 2021) — Michigan Courts
  3. MCL 28.425b(22)(c) — Michigan Legislature
  4. MCL 28.425b(22)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  5. OAG, 2003, No 7133 (May 2, 2003), as quoted in the MJI Domestic Violence Benchbook §6.5(D) — Michigan Judicial Institute, Domestic Violence Benchbook
  6. *American Axle & Mfg, Inc v City of Hamtramck*, 461 Mich 352, 373 (2000), as quoted in MJI Domestic Violence Benchbook (4th ed) § 6.5, nn 43–44 — Michigan Judicial Institute, Domestic Violence Benchbook
  7. MCR 7.121(C)(1); MCR 7.104(A)(1) — Michigan Courts
  8. MCL 28.425d(1), (2) — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCL 28.425b(22)(b); MCL 28.425b(7)(f), (h), (i) — Michigan Legislature
  10. MCL 750.224f(1) — Michigan Legislature
  11. 28 CFR 107.30(a) — govinfo.gov
  12. *In re Schultz*, 334 Mich App 730 (2020), n 2 (citing *United States v Kenny*, 375 F Supp 2d 622, 625 (ED Mich, 2005), and *United States v Brown*, 69 F Supp 2d 925, 944 (ED Mich, 1999)) — Michigan Courts
  13. MCL 780.622(1), (3), (7), (9) — Michigan Legislature
  14. *Mothering Justice v Attorney General*, Court of Appeals No. 362271 (26 January 2023) (Riordan, J., concurring), quoting *League of Women Voters of Mich v Secretary of State*, 508 Mich 520, 567 n 24 (2022) — Michigan Courts
  15. MCL 28.425b(8) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 28.425b(11) — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCL 28.425b(11), (13)(a)–(c) — Michigan Legislature
  18. MCR 7.121(A), (B) — Michigan Courts
  19. SCAO form CC 79 (Rev. 6/18); MCL 28.425d; MCL 28.428; MCR 7.121 — courts.mi.gov
  20. MCL 28.425d(2)–(4) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.