SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · If you were arrested or charged

Preparing for Sentencing in a Michigan Drug Case: The Presentence Report and the Hearing

Key points

  • Before sentencing a person on a felony, or a licensed or registered health professional, a probation officer must investigate and give the court a written presentence report; in other misdemeanor cases this happens only if the court directs it.[1]
  • The defendant, the defense lawyer and the prosecutor may review the report before sentencing, and a copy is due at least 2 business days ahead unless the defendant waives that time.[2][3]
  • Either side may challenge inaccurate or irrelevant information on the record; if the court agrees, the information is struck before the report goes to the Department of Corrections.[4]
  • Before imposing sentence, the judge must address the defendant personally to permit the defendant to speak or present any information to mitigate the sentence.[5][6]

Sentencing in a Michigan felony drug case starts before the hearing, with a presentence investigation by a probation officer who writes a report for the judge.[1] The defendant has a right to review that report, to challenge information in it, and to speak to the judge before the sentence is imposed.[2][4][5]

This page explains the process step by step. It does not predict any sentence or suggest what anyone should say; the penalties themselves are on the drug sentencing page and the penalties chart.

When a presentence report is prepared

Under MCL 771.14, before the court sentences a person charged with a felony, the probation officer must look into the person's background, character and circumstances and report in writing to the court.[1] In other misdemeanor cases, the officer does this only if the court directs it.[1] A licensed or registered health professional also gets a presentence investigation before sentencing.[1]

The felony court rules, MCR 6.425, set out the same investigation and add procedures for disclosure and challenges.[7][8] District court misdemeanor cases follow a separate sentencing rule, MCR 6.610(G), covered below.[9][6]

What goes into the report

MCR 6.425 says the report must be succinct and, depending on the circumstances, include the following:[7]

  • Prior criminal convictions and juvenile adjudications, and a complete description of the offense.[7]
  • Work history, military record and present employment, plus a brief social history covering items such as marital status, finances, education and length of residence in the community.[7]
  • The defendant's medical history, substance abuse history, if any, and, if indicated, a current psychological or psychiatric report.[7]
  • Harm suffered by any victim, and a written victim impact statement if provided and requested by the victim.[7]
  • Any statement the defendant wishes to make.[7]
  • The prosecutor's statement on any consecutive sentencing provision, an evaluation and prognosis for the defendant's adjustment in the community, and a specific recommendation for disposition.[7]

The statute adds that, for a guidelines felony, the report must include the guidelines grid and the computation of the recommended minimum range, a specific statement on whether intermediate sanctions apply, and the recommended sentence.[10] For a felony or a misdemeanor involving the illegal delivery, possession or use of a controlled substance, it must also state whether the person holds a health-profession license or registration, if applicable.[10]

The presentence interview

On request, the probation officer must give the defense lawyer notice of the presentence interview and a reasonable opportunity to attend it.[11] The court rule lists "any statement the defendant wishes to make" among the contents of the report.[7] What to say, if anything, is a question for the defendant and the defense lawyer; this guide does not give that advice.

On the practical side, papers such as proof of a job, school enrollment, or attendance at counseling or treatment are easier to share if they are gathered before the interview, with copies kept for the defendant and the defense lawyer.

Treatment, assessments and drug education

Before sentencing for a drug offense, MCL 333.7408a lets the court order a screening and assessment to decide whether the person is likely to benefit from rehabilitative services such as drug education or treatment, and the person pays for it.[12] As part of the sentence the court may order up to 90 days of unpaid community service and completion of one or more rehabilitative programs, again at the person's cost.[13] Neither power applies to a person who is not eligible for probation.[12][13]

Separately, for drug convictions other than narcotic or cocaine delivery or manufacture and possession of 25 grams or more of a narcotic or cocaine, the court may require a course on the medical, psychological and social effects of drug misuse during jail or probation, and failing to complete it is a probation violation.[14] The statutory definition of an "intermediate sanction" includes inpatient or outpatient drug treatment and participation in a drug treatment court.[15]

Reviewing the report and challenging errors

The court must let the prosecutor, the defense lawyer and the defendant review the report before sentencing.[2] A copy is due at least 2 business days before sentencing unless the defendant waives that period, and the defense may keep the report and any amended report.[3] In a felony case, if the report is not available two business days ahead, either side is entitled on oral motion to an adjournment to review it and prepare corrections.[8]

The court may withhold information that could seriously disrupt a rehabilitation program, or sources promised confidentiality, but it must tell the parties that something was withheld and state its reasons on the record.[8]

At sentencing, either party may challenge the accuracy or relevancy of any information in the report.[4] The court must let both sides be heard and either make a finding or decide it will not take the information into account.[16] If the court finds information inaccurate or irrelevant, the report is amended and the information is struck before the report goes to the Department of Corrections.[4] The defense lawyer gets to review the corrected report before it is sent, and no earlier version may be used for prison classification, programming or parole.[16]

The 2-business-day rule is a minimum. When the report actually becomes available, and how it is shared, varies by court.[3]

Guidelines scoring

For felonies, proposed scoring of the sentencing guidelines must accompany the presentence report.[17] The guidelines produce a recommended range for the minimum sentence; the statute says the minimum "may be" within that range, and a departure must be reasonable with reasons stated on the record.[18] When the top of the range is 18 months or less, the statute calls for an intermediate sanction unless the court states reasonable grounds for jail or prison, but since People v Lockridge courts may, but are no longer required to, impose one.[15][19] How drug offenses are scored, including offense variable 15 for drug quantity, is covered on the sentencing guidelines page.

What happens at the felony sentencing hearing

MCR 6.425(D) lists what the judge must do on the record:[5][20]

  1. Confirm that the defendant, the defense lawyer and the prosecutor have had a chance to read and discuss the report.[5]
  2. Give each side a chance to explain or challenge information in it, and resolve any challenge.[5]
  3. Let the defense lawyer speak on the defendant's behalf.[5]
  4. Address the defendant personally, to permit the defendant to speak or present any information to mitigate the sentence.[5]
  5. Give the prosecutor an equivalent chance to speak, and let any victim who is present, or the victim's designee, make an impact statement.[5]
  6. State the sentence, including the minimum and maximum if applicable, with any credit for time served, and give reasons for any departure from the guidelines range.[20]

Time spent in jail before sentencing because bond was denied or could not be posted must be credited against the sentence.[21] A felony prison sentence is indeterminate: the judge sets the minimum, and the maximum is the one provided by law.[22] A sentence with a maximum of 1 year or less is served in the county jail, not a state prison.[23] The court also imposes minimum state costs of $68 for a felony and a crime victim rights assessment of $130 for a felony.[24][25][26]

Sentencing in district court misdemeanor cases

For a misdemeanor drug case in district court, MCR 6.610(G) requires copies of a presentence report, if one was prepared, at least two business days before sentencing.[6] Before imposing sentence the judge must let the defense lawyer speak, address the defendant personally to permit the defendant to speak or present mitigating information, let the prosecutor speak, and tell the defendant what credit for time served, if any, will be given.[6] After a jail sentence, even a suspended one, the court must explain that a request for an appointed appellate lawyer is due within 14 days after sentencing.[27]

After the sentence

The court must sign a written judgment of sentence within 7 days.[28] After a felony sentence, the judge must explain appeal rights: after a trial, a request for an appointed appellate lawyer is due within 42 days to appeal by right; after a guilty or no-contest plea, the request is due within 6 months, and the appeal is by application for leave.[29][30] All the time limits are collected in the drug case deadlines calendar.

A sentence of probation brings its own conditions and testing rules, explained in drug probation and testing. If the case may end with a section 7411 deferral or HYTA, those pages explain how the deferral works instead of a conviction.

Common questions

Do I get to read my presentence report before I am sentenced?

Yes. Michigan law requires the court to let the prosecutor, the defense lawyer and the defendant review the report before sentencing.[2] The copy is due at least 2 business days before sentencing unless the defendant waives that period, and both sides may keep a copy.[3] In a felony case, if the report arrives late, either side is entitled on oral motion to an adjournment to review it and prepare corrections.[8]

What happens if the presentence report gets my record or the facts wrong?

Either party may challenge the accuracy or relevancy of information in the report on the record at sentencing.[4] The court must hear the challenge and either make a finding or decide it will not consider the information.[16] If the court finds the information inaccurate or irrelevant, the report is amended and the information is struck before the report is sent to the Department of Corrections.[4]

Can the judge order a drug assessment before sentencing?

Yes, for a defendant who is eligible for probation. Before sentencing for a drug offense, the court may order a screening and assessment to decide whether the person is likely to benefit from drug education or treatment, and the person pays for it.[12] As part of the sentence the court may also order up to 90 days of community service or completion of rehabilitative programs.[13]

Is there a presentence report in a misdemeanor drug case?

Only if the court directs one, unless the person is a licensed or registered health professional. The statute requires a report before felony sentencing and before sentencing such a licensee or registrant, and in other misdemeanor cases only when the court orders it.[1] If a report was prepared in a district court case, the rule requires copies at least two business days before sentencing.[6] Practice varies by court, so the court's notice or the defense lawyer is the place to confirm whether one is being prepared.

Does jail time served before sentencing count?

Time spent in jail before sentencing because bond was denied or could not be posted must be credited against the sentence for that offense.[21] In a felony case the judge states the sentence on the record together with any credit for time served to which the defendant is entitled.[20] A district court judge must tell the defendant what credit, if any, will be given.[6]

Sources

  1. MCL 771.14(1) — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCL 771.14(5) — Michigan Legislature
  3. MCL 771.14(7) — Michigan Legislature
  4. MCL 771.14(6) — Michigan Legislature
  5. MCR 6.425(D)(1)(a)-(c) — Michigan Courts
  6. MCR 6.610(G)(1)(b)-(d) — Michigan Courts
  7. MCR 6.425(A)(1) — Michigan Courts
  8. MCR 6.425(B) — Michigan Courts
  9. MCR 6.001(A), (B) — Michigan Courts
  10. MCL 771.14(2)(a)-(f) — Michigan Legislature
  11. MCR 6.425(A)(2) — Michigan Courts
  12. MCL 333.7408a(1), (3) — Michigan Legislature
  13. MCL 333.7408a(1)–(3) — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCL 333.7411(5) — Michigan Legislature
  15. MCL 769.34(4)(a); MCL 769.31(b) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCR 6.425(D)(2)(a) — Michigan Courts
  17. MCR 6.425(C) — Michigan Courts
  18. MCL 769.34(2), (3) — Michigan Legislature
  19. Michigan Judicial Institute, Criminal Proceedings Benchbook Vol. 2, §1.8 (PDF page 39), citing People v Lockridge, 498 Mich 358, 365 n 1 (2015), and People v Schrauben, 314 Mich App 181, 194-195 (2016) — Michigan Courts
  20. MCR 6.425(D)(1)(d)-(f) — Michigan Courts
  21. MCL 769.11b — Michigan Legislature
  22. MCL 769.8(1) — Michigan Legislature
  23. MCL 769.28 — Michigan Legislature
  24. MCL 769.1j(1), (3) — Michigan Legislature
  25. MCL 769.1k(1) — Michigan Legislature
  26. MCL 780.905(1), (2) — Michigan Legislature
  27. MCR 6.610(G)(4) — Michigan Courts
  28. MCR 6.427; MCR 6.001(B) — Michigan Courts
  29. MCR 6.425(F)(1)-(3) — Michigan Courts
  30. MCR 6.302(B)(5) — Michigan Courts

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.